Reviewed: [title of show]
Tone Deaf Theatre Company has embarked upon a particularly challenging show in [title of show]. This one-act musical follows the story of its own development and, as described within the show, ‘it’s about two guys writing a musical about two guys writing a musical about two guys writing a musical.’ Sound complicated? It is. And yet it is beautifully enjoyable and brilliantly funny.
Director John Muething should be highly praised for taking on such a challenge and making a success of it. Simon Lynch was, of course, fantastic. His incredible vocal talent cannot go unmentioned, but what made his performance particularly impressive in this show was his fantastic characterization, which was consistent and believable throughout. He played the show’s writer, Hunter Bell, with an excitable energy that gave a real buzz to the whole production.
Lynch’s flamboyant Hunter was beautifully juxtaposed with the more reserved Jeff, (Ben Gittins). The onstage relationship between Lynch and Gittins was excellent and the contrast between them was portrayed beautifully; their duet of ‘Two Nobodies in New York’ was a personal highlight.
Gittins should be commended for holding his own and not being overshadowed by Lynch’s excitable Hunter. Even with a more reserved character Gittins successfully managed to maintain a presence that captured our attention. He gave an endearing performance, and I found myself growing to love ‘Jeffy’ and empathized with his trials of trying to make his mark on the theatre industry.
The girls too gave exceptional performances. Rozi Prekop was beautifully ridiculous as the quirky Susan and Elissa Churchill’s Heidi was controlled and professional.
On the whole I felt in safe hands with the entire cast and could have easily been watching a professional production instead of an amateur student show. As an ensemble the cast was remarkable. Vocally they blended beautifully together and the harmonies were executed perfectly. Some of the best moments were when all four sang together. They created an incredibly rich sound that filled the entire space of the Assembly Rooms.
Musical Director Chris Guard deserves praise for the professionalism of all the songs. The group numbers were tight and together, which is a hard task to master when considering the difficulty of the music of this show. Guard must also be praised for single-handedly accompanying the music of the show on both the keys and percussion!
Dan Gosselin has once again excelled himself as Technical Director. The technical aspects of the production were smoothly executed throughout. I was particularly impressed by the use of lighting and enjoyed the interesting effects such as hanging lamps and flashing fairy lights. The consistency of the lighting direction helped to clarify the development of the plot.
The blackouts between scene changes did not need to be as long as they sometimes were. Had this been addressed, this may have improved the pace and seamlessness of the production. Since the set was particularly minimalist, the scene changes could have been very quick. In general though, the stark, bare set, comprising merely of four chairs, was used effectively. However, the two swivel chairs proved problematic at times with the wheels getting caught or rolling too far.
I would have to disagree with the claims (mentioned in the show) from the ‘broadway.com’ review that the songs are ‘forgettable’ – I have been humming ‘Two Nobodies in New York’ since I left the theatre. I would also disagree with Hunter’s claim that reviews should be ignored and I hope the cast and production team revel in the fact that this reviewer loved it.
This was the perfect final show for the Assembly Rooms this year, and a triumph for all involved.
Photographs: Naomi Ellis

![[titleofshow]](https://i0.wp.com/www.palatinate.org.uk/wp-content/uploadedImages/titleofshow-300x200.jpg?resize=300%2C200)