Reviewed: Sir Thomas Allen at Durham Cathedral
Not every university music society gets the opportunity to perform with a world class baritone, nevermind their own Chancellor, and an augmented Durham University Chamber Choir and Orchestral Society tonight certainly reveled in the chance to sing with Sir Thomas Allen in Durham Cathedral.
The name of Allen to most Durham students usually conjures images of Johnny Woodgates and Klute pre-drinking, but a year after his appointment as Chancellor of the University, Sir Thomas has certainly given Jimmy A’s a run for their money. Calum Zuckert, Student Music Co-ordinator as well as conductor of the Chamber Choir and DUOS this year, has surely fulfilled his aim of encouraging interaction between the Chancellor and the student music scene as well as “championing the cause” of bringing Durham’s varying music societies together; the staging of the Cathedral was full to the brim, with the orchestra surrounded not only the Chamber Choir but several other singers from chapel choirs and producing a powerful vocal force for the esteemed soloist to reckon.
However, what is immediately apparent is that Sir Thomas Allen is not the only experienced performer here tonight. These may be students, but they are by no means unprepared or unused to this kind of setting. All the singers here have emerged from auditioned choirs that, thanks to those running them, are consistently challenged with difficult and compelling pieces to sing. The programme is, therefore, a varied offering, and notably British following on from the chamber choir’s theme of ‘Britain and Britten’ this year. Beginning with William Walton’s ‘The Twelve’ (with Sir Thomas sneakily joining the basses in the back row before his formal appearance in the second half), the Chamber Choir sang excellently. As a performing arena the Cathedral poses several difficulties, ranging from the travel of acoustics to the audience’s ability to simply see you behind huge columns, but the Chamber Choir coped very well under these unique pressures; their techniques as individual singers must be commended especially under the unforgiving scrutiny of the cameras that led to television screens around the building, during which any potential signs of staggered breathing or moments of nerves still went unnoticed.
The programme of the first half continued with Gavin Bryers’ ‘Lord I cry unto Thee‘ and Tallis’ ‘In Ieinio et fletu’, perfect choices to be performed in the Cathedral setting and the a capella nature of them providing a very intense and concentrated sound. As far as soloists go, Camilla Harris in Britten’s ‘Rejoice in the Lamb’ was unparalleled in her clear tone, and Eleanor Penfold’s in the Walton was also an education in confidence and control. The stand out performance was, however, the penultimate piece; ‘Unto Dust’, which was commissioned for the choir, was itself written by one of its basses, Ben Rowarth, and as Calum Zuckert also mentioned, showed a breathtaking eye and ear for composition which the university should leap onto with greedy hands with its own commissions before Ben is whisked away into what will undoubtedly be a promising musical career. The piece was haunting and brilliantly captured the sense of the original text – ‘Unto Dust thou shalt return’ – from Ash Wednesday in its moving, even vulnerable harmonies.
The second half of the concert was a homage to Ralph Vaughan Williams, including the nice touch of including Tallis’ ‘Why Fum’th in Fight’ right before the orchestra warmed the building with a performance of Vaughan Williams’ ‘Fantasia on a Theme’ by Thomas Tallis. Sir Thomas’ entrance commanded the same presence it did the night before, in his sole rehearsal with the students before the performance. The president of DUOS, Jessica Lawrence, noticed amusingly that Friday night how immediately the orchestra “sat up straighter”, and I myself felt a hush of respect and wonder – “Is that him?” one perplexed violinist audibly asked – as he walked up and shook hands with the conductor.
Despite this, of course, Sir Thomas Allen is by no means a pompous or self-indulgent opera singer. In the rehearsal he was eager to introduce himself to the student music body and admitted “I’m terrified about this – this is my audition for the university.” His background in local student music programmes like Samling already show his involvement with encouraging musicality in the young, and throughout the rehearsal he is a perfect mix of appreciative and informative in singing with them. In speaking to him myself he’s extremely amiable and funny, and he admitted to nerves but said that “the art of performing is to know how to control them.” He discussed the programme with Calum as it was decided, and with me Sir Thomas passionately discussed the Vaughan Williams pieces in particular. He famously sang the ‘Five Mystical Songs’ at the 2004 BBC Proms but he told me that “this is where it belongs” in the enormity of the Cathedral, allowing the long and lyrical phrases to arch like they should do. His voice, however, also seems to have been born to sing here. In his solo right at the very beginning in the Walton his baritone, throbbing timbre of a voice has all the boom of an Old Testament God; yet here, reprising the Vaughan Williams, he sculpts his voice into a soothing, intelligent and dove-like handling of the romantic text. The addition of chapel choir singers, drawn mostly from Hild Bede, Hatfield and Castle, combine with the huge orchestra and the formidable Sir Thomas to create a brilliant sound that certainly does justice to the Chancellor’s desire for a performance that seemed to be tailor-made to Vaughan Williams’ pieces.
The concert ends, and there are beaming faces all around. Sir Thomas certainly looks pleased with a bottle of wine and a painting of the Cathedral which have kindly been gifted to him, and hopefully his immense amount of influence and the success of this fine performance will lure more top soloists to come to the university and join the students in more fantastic concerts. More importantly, hopefully both students and the local community will respond positively to this performance in wanting to attend more of the university’s classical music produce, especially in an area that is so well-esteemed for choral music; when I spoke to Sir Thomas I couldn’t avoid bringing up how the concert proved that the old trope of ‘we need to get kids into classical music’ was irrelevant here in an arena of nearly 200 student performers, and his response to the wheedling of people who do not see this progress was a weary ‘I get it all the time.’ Despite our agreement, on the other hand, I could not help but notice that I was surrounded by grey heads and Northern voices; it was a student concert, but not a student audience. The personality of Sir Thomas Allen is so big and humorous that it is a great shame many students missed a somewhat rare sighting of him, amidst his busy working schedule, to see not only a world-class performer but their Chancellor sing in our own Cathedral. The concert did, however, provide invaluable experience for the student performers, and also for the student organisers who learnt what it is to work alongside big time soloists. A truly remarkable concert that shall surely be the start of many exciting music projects to come.

