Reviewed: Orcs! The Musical

by Gabriel Samuels

When I ask Reesha Dyer, writer-director of Orcs: The Musical, what her aim was in conjuring up this original production on a shoe-string budget and framing it as a parody of musical theatre, she says simply “Just to try and make people laugh”. The Fountains Hall Theatre in Grey College, reopened as a venue following a series of fire-safety issues, was transformed into the plains of far-away Astra Rubis, where blood-thirsty Orcs and Urka do battle; romance blossoms between the Urka princess Claudia and HaAfa the lowly Orc warrior; and together they overcome the evil tyranny of the King’s advisor Frey. Pretty standard musical fare, you might think; an easy premise to pull off in a way that is funny and entertaining for both audience and cast, you might think. Yet Orcs managed to make it seem like a chore.

The main thing you have to remember when you’re performing a parody is that it’s meant to be funny. A flow of chuckles should remain fairly consistent throughout the performance – this, after-all, was Dyer’s aim, and the audience haven’t exactly come for riveting drama. If it’s musical theatre parody, you expect wittily reworked ensemble numbers; if there’s orcs included you anticipate geeky puns and nerd culture references galore. Dyer reworded a catalogue of musical hits for the production – numbers from the Sound of Music, Cabaret, Grease, and Oklahoma – to fit her narrative, but there was nothing clever or droll about the way in which it was done, with so much scope for humour. And that’s only the beginning.

The choreography was under-rehearsed and lacked any dynamism; the quality of singing varied wildly between the impressive vocals of Princess Claudia and Chater and the sub-standard warblings of other ensemble members. Dyer tried valiantly to create personalities around which to frame a narrative –  the gawky demonologist MattMatt, the demonic and manipulative Frey, the camp and temperamental fashionista Jason – but was let down badly by her cast, all of whom made weak attempts at filling their characters. Only David Whittle as the fruity-voiced Narrator made any attempt to inject life and persona into a production that sagged horribly under the weight of its own neutrality – he alone cracked jokes that actually made the audience laugh. The costumes, particularly the one belonging to the Urka King Michael, were impressive, and the musical accompaniment endearingly low-budget – but glaring cracks elsewhere were far too big to paper over.

Dyer’s script was solid but not funny. Laughs were painfully few and far between; there was not one allusion to Lord of the Rings; and any jokes attempted were basic yet still delivered with agonizing awkwardness. Dyer is not entirely at fault for this – the acting was tentative at best, embarrassing to watch at worst. It’s perfectly acceptable to do something for a bit of fun at least make it fun and have fun yourselves in doing it. Funding may have been limited but putting energy into a performance, loosening up and giving it 110% with added smiles costs nothing and would have made Orcs highly watchable; its absence was unforgivable, with even opportunities for physical comedy neutralised by awkwardness. As a performance it felt sluggish, quiet and monotonous – at times I had to remind myself I was meant to be watching a musical. As the audience was reminded with exhausting insistence, “Orc is the word”. For everyone present the word will forever be associated with a night that fell well short of its billing.

**