Reviewed: Cables From Kabul
Cables from Kabul is a five part series filmed by ‘Vice news’ that is broadcast on their website www.vicenews.com. It’s purpose is both noble and commendable, to expose the problems inherent within Afghanistan. According to ‘Vice’ these are obscured by politicians desperate to sell a positive picture. Regardless, their purpose is admirable and seems to be accomplished.
The audience watches as the camera enters the darkness of Kabul. We are exposed to her worst prison, squalors containing the most addictive and harmful drugs and men whose sexual fantasies are fulfilled by young boys. The deprivation is rammed down your throat, whilst the narrator tells of the security threats endemic within Afghanistan society. It is essentially a list of problems and evils, punctuated by little happiness, or even hope.
My problem with this programme is twofold. Firstly you don’t see any woman. Not one, not even in the street. I’m not sure if Vice didn’t interview women simply because they couldn’t access them or if their concern was focused on men. However the result was that the womens’ plight in Afghanistan was largely ignored. This was a shame because in every country there is an underworld. In England crack dens also exist. This is tragic, but it is not specific to Afghanistan, it is a universal shame. So why not mention the plight of women, which is surely more specific to Kabul and, certainly relevant considering the rise of Islamic extremism? If they couldn’t be interviewed because of misogynistic values why wasn’t this mentioned? Whilst I learnt a lot from this programme, I felt they were missing out on a vital part of the problem; half of the populace was ignored.
Furthermore their cameras were looking for problems. Media has a responsibility to report the whole picture, but ‘Vice’ went into Kabul with a certain angle intent on showing us the failings of the government. Like ignoring the women, they also ignored the normality, the positive. After watching it I felt more confused than ever, because whilst reporting on a collapsing society I saw a fairground, traffic, children playing. I am not suggesting that life in Kabul is anywhere close to acceptable, or that we should ignore the numerous problems. I do, however, feel that for a 5 part series a lot was missing. Certainly it was informative and, in their defense, the footage was not sensationalised in any way. It was realistic and did a good job of letting the material, and the people of Kabul speak for themselves. This was done by not patronising the subjects or using any heavy narration. It also made me want to learn more, but I fear that was largely to do with the gaps in the content rather than the programme itself. Certainly useful, but a tad limited.

