Derren Brown: Genius or Fraud?
Derren Brown’s latest television four-part special, The Experiments’s, features him hypnotising someone to unknowingly assassinate a celebrity, recruit a games show audience to demonstrate ‘mob mentality’, convince someone to confess to a crime they didn’t commit, and manufacture a local legend in a small community.
This new assault on human understanding will inevitably revitalise the discussion over whether the magician is a genius or a fraud. However this is not easy to distinguish, as Brown is a genius because of how he is a fraud. The self-proclaimed illusionist and mentalists uses “magic, suggestion, psychology, misdirection and showmanship”, as he states at the start of all of his programs, in order to achieve a vast variety of stunts that often stun the nation, such as mind control and spot-on prediction (we’ll let him off for predicting that roulette ball one place off).
Now the main arguments that critics of Brown will use against him is that he is a fraud: he does not do any of the processes he claims, that he just uses hired actors to allow him to fake his tricks. I personally believe these critics are only half-right, and that is what shows Brown’s genius.
If you strip down Brown’s act to the bare minimum, he’s a magician and an illusionist. And what do these professions do? They lie (sorry kids, but the Easter Bunny isn’t real either). We like to believe as the audience that Brown is different from other entertainers of his kind, as he starts off every trick by saying that he has no magical powers and is just using clever psychology. But just because he admits this does not believe that he is being completely and honestly open about his methods.
For example take his televised show “Something Wicked This Way Comes”, which took a Laurence Olivier Award in 2006. Here Brown accurately predicted that a random audience member would accurately pick the word “inevitable” off a random page from a random newspaper, and told his audience that he did so by subtly brainwashing them throughout the show, showing them earlier cues. Do you really believe that he risked ruining the climax of his show by performing this trick as he stated, which had miniscule odds of working? Or, more likely, he had a pre-arranged a formula to predict and control which word would be chosen (e.g. the eleventh word in every article in the papers was “inevitable”)? The latter method has been done by other magicians on a smaller scale.
Either Brown can actually do all the tricks as he says he does, which is damn near impossible, or he is cunning enough to dress up different, yet still genius, methods as miracles. In the end a magician is just a performer, and a genius performer dupes the audience in the most imaginative way he can. So you have a nice choice: you can praise Brown for the ingenious methods and presentation, or his post-modern reinvention of the magician trade.

