Review: The Magic Flute

By Katja Garson

Rose Innes magic flute

Finally entering the Great Hall to see Durham Opera Ensemble’s The Magic Flute, I was struck by the magical atmosphere created by the combination of the starry lighting at the back of the stage and the grand architecture. I felt that this opening setting worked well.

From the beginning it was clear that each singer possessed a fine voice, well-suited to each role.

The famous Queen of the Night Aria from Bridget Tomlinson was followed by a shower of applause.

Tomlinson possesses a powerful voice, which nevertheless also managed well in moments of delicacy.

Her pitching was generally perfect, with slight slips at the top end of the aria, but this did not detract from the overall effect.

Milly Harris’s Pamina was feminine and believable. Her clear, liquid voice lent itself well to varied situations and her sorrowful lament was especially touching, in contrast with the more light-hearted piece sung with the three cheery boys (Rebecca Madden, Rebecca Meltzer, and Jessy Croghan).

Many laughs were had thanks to Papageno (Lewis Whyte), whose comical character inspired sympathy and affection, and whose acting talent was particularly notable. This can also be said of Papagena (Hatty Ekbery).

Hugo Hymas’s Tamino was suitably gallant, his emotive singing fitting the part well, while James Quitmann had a rich and reassuring voice, perfect for the fatherly Sarastro.

I cannot detail every voice here, but each singer demonstrated great talent and confidence.

The Great Hall does not lend itself well acoustically, however the production dealt with this well. Although at times the professional-sounding orchestra drowned out snatches of singing, and Tamino’s ‘flute’ was not always in time with the real flute, in general it was well-balanced.

A note on a practical problem: whilst those sitting nearer the front will have had a different experience, sitting towards the back highlighted problems with visibility.

Good use was made of the aisles in the entrances and exits of various characters, a simple yet effective use of the space of the hall.

Anna Bailey’s decision to set the opera in London during the aftermath of the Second World War was a clever idea, although before I had read the programme I was not sure what this gave to the production.

Nevertheless, the adoption of this period was meaningful, the post-war context lending a sense of fragility to the otherwise playful production as the cast strove to realise their dreams and ambitions.

Thunder-claps and bright flashes added well to this fearful undertone. The context also allowed for some fun costumes, and the use of architectural pillars on set was striking and effective.

This was a vibrant and touching performance from DOE, with each singer succeeding in bringing across their individual personalities and, importantly, looking like they enjoyed every moment.

Although issues of audibility and especially visibility were at times a hindrance, the performance conveyed perfectly the struggles of loss and fear. The final triumph of good over evil and love over hate reminded us what life is all about.

Photograph: Rose Innes