Review: The Admirable Crichton
By Hannah Atkinson

The Admirable Crichton is an ambitious undertaking by the Fountains Theatre Company.
In J. M. Barrie’s unorthodox pantomime, the British class system is turned on its head as Lord Loam’s progressive views on equality between master and servant are put to the test when his household, including his exceedingly competent butler, Crichton, is shipwrecked on a desert island during a yachting holiday.
Transported into a world of warthogs and coconuts, it is a game of survival of the fittest for the Loam family, and the practical Crichton takes over as leader when a new hierarchical order forms, only to be forced to return to the original dynamics when the family are rescued and restored to their Victorian sitting room.
The cast gives a lively and engaging performance, while the impressive scene changes, sound, lighting, and hilarious props, including a delightful range of animal plush toys and hula skirts, carry us into a subverted order.
Although off to a bumpy start, the actors seemed to quickly grow into their roles.
By the time of the shipwreck, Lord Loam (Adam Cook) and the memorable Tweeney (Eleanor Bowness) were keeping the laughs coming with their excellent handling of slapstick, an admirable feat considering the cosy stage space.
The Reverend Treherne, played by Eleanor Smith, particularly comes into his own in the second act, sporting a fantastic beard with a liberating effect, a personal highlight.
Jess Taylor as Ernest nails the Wilde-inspired wit, and although all the cast did at some point trip over the long lines of nineteenth century rhetoric, these minor mistakes did not distract from the charm of their portrayals.
The cast of the three sisters, Agatha, Catherine and Mary (Josie Williams, Naomi Denny, Elizabeth Gray), clearly relished their transformative roles.
Their renditions of snobbish upper-class caricatures who learn to cast off their corsets and hunt for monkey meat with surprising adeptness was particularly comical.
In this world of farce and satire, however, it was the developing romance between Crichton and Mary that brought the play to its bittersweet close.
Elizabeth Blackmore as Crichton and Elizabeth Gray as Mary controlled their transitioning love dynamic well, as what starts out as comic sexual tension ends in painful parting.
When the family are discovered and their utopian world shattered, Crichton and Mary’s choice to ‘play the game’, as they return from benign dictator and loyal subject to servant and mistress, is made artfully compelling by the actors’ use of silence and gesture.
The director, Ralph Weiner, makes an effective choice in bringing just the right amount of poignancy to this farcical world: the Countess of Brocklehurst beautifully handled the reappearance of the warthog in the sitting room in the final scene, keeping a light touch to an appropriately subdued and thought-provoking ending.
Fountains Theatre Company handled a challenging set and script with a balance of outrageous absurdity and dramatic control. A good laugh with a political twist.
Photograph: Laura Clifford
