5 hours, 13 coffee shops

coffee

By Harry Granger

Thursday was a write-off for work from the moment I left the house. Even with workshop reading and deadlines mounting, the work would have to wait. I was determined to unravel the intricacies of Durham’s coffee culture once and for all, with a complete scouring of Durham’s coffee landscape. With so very many cafés located across the city centre and the burgeoning popularity of coffee houses as a hub of student social life, the importance of my mission cannot be refuted.

£25.30, 13 coffee shops and 5 hours later and I have carried out the most complete review of the coffee situation in Durham to date. My plan had initially been to compare the cheapest available coffee in every location, but after my first three Espressos and growing concerns that my heart-beat was becoming increasingly irregular, I decided to sample a wider variety of coffee types on a fairly random basis. I can only presume that a café capable of a fine cappuccino is probably likely to produce other varieties of coffee to a similar standard anyway.

So, the coffee marathon began at Chapters of Durham, where I enjoyed a delightful Espresso, which required no fiddling with and was quite pleasantly (and uniquely in Durham as it turns out) brought to me at my table. I must say, this was one of the best coffees I had all day. Served with a glass of water to complement the warming, caramel taste of the beverage, Chapters is a fine combination of local charm and (I presume) Italian expertise.

Chapters deserves a 9 out of 10, perhaps benefiting from the fact that I enjoyed a great panino there and Chapters’ “Famous Hand-Cut Chips”, but nevertheless should be a front-runner for your custom.

Unfortunately, this was followed by a pretty boring and uninspired spell in the Durham coffee chains: Costa, Starbucks, Caffe Nero and Esquires. While the open and stylish interior of Durham’s new Starbucks was fairy impressive and the benefits of loyalty offers and familiarity in these chains are clearly attractive, none of these venues had much to offer in terms of character, coffee or service. The main offender of these four was Esquires, which felt a bit like a messy bus shelter and in which the froth-art was probably the only things distinguishing my £2.15 Latte from a mug of tepid milk.

I think a 5 or 6 out of 10 score for these is probably about fair.

Irritatingly things got quite a lot worse before they got better. 2 sips into my Americano at Treats, I admit I was questioning the value of my quest. Even with about 40 gruff employees faffing around the counter, it took 10 minutes to get a coffee as I stood around like a lemon waiting for someone to “nip out and get some milk.” The coffee tasted pretty weird with the quite ‘vegetable-y’ undertones and the large pile of pans lurking in the sink behind the counter was slightly alarming. So I would say that Treats is probably one of the milder treats I have experienced.

Possibly not worth scaling the stairs there: 4/10.

All the staff conversed with each other in Italian, with orders barked out from the counter to ‘Generale’

After all of this, and some time spent outside Treats debating whether to continue, came Caffé Capriccio. Without doubt the surprise package of the day; don’t let the dingy appearance fool you, the cappuccino was superb. More importantly though, this shop had the most unique character of all of those visited. All the staff conversed with each other in Italian, with orders barked out from the counter to ‘Generale’, a moustached Italian gentleman in an apron, who bumbled around sorting out my coffee and spoke at me for several minutes in Italian as I thanked him for bringing my coffee over.

Why bother flying to Rome when you can experience Italy at the top of Elvet Bridge? 8/10.

Flat White, Cottons, Alms and Café Continental were all fairly uneventful visits. The food at Café Continental and Flat White looked pretty good but as coffee outlets neither was spectacular. The pew seats and stacked bookshelves made for a good atmosphere at Flat White, but it was quite busy and the coffee was so-so. At Leonard’s, admittedly rather controversially, I went for the White Chocolate Latte and the less said about that the better. However, I am told that, had I made a more rational coffee decision, I might have been more satisfied.

In terms of coffee at least I think these five score in the 6-7/10 region.

It was getting pretty dark as I headed up Claypath for my final visit of the day to the Claypath Delicatessen. Fittingly this comfy and quiet location offered an excellent Cinnamon –Spiced Mocha, alongside what I had previously established to be a cracking array of sandwiches. The coffee was warming and more-ish even after 12 coffees, allowing me to conclude my investigation on a very positive note.

8/10. Though if you were to eat there too, Claypath Deli probably deserves a 9.5/10.

In conclusion, Durham has a lot of coffee shops and it probably isn’t worth going to all of them, especially not all in one day. Definite highlights included Chapters, for an Espresso and Tuna Panino; Caffé Capriccio for excellent coffee and to observe ‘Generale’, and the Claypath Delicatessen, for either an exotic coffee or delicious lunch. 13 coffee shops in 5 hours…so now you know.

Photograph: Diana Grant-Davie