Review: Sweeney Todd: A Musical Thriller

11034227_10203935066799163_2329572440549021090_n

By Kennedy Cassy.

From the very beginning Van Mildert College knew they were taking on an ambitious project with Sweeney Todd: A Musical Thriller. Stephen Sondheim’s musicals are notorious for their complex scores and demanding vocals. Yet, despite a few drawbacks, on the whole Van Mildert rose to the occasion and delivered a powerful performance which revealed the considerable talent and hard-work of those involved.

Sweeney Todd: A Musical Thriller, one of Sondheim’s most disturbing musicals, is based on the 1973 play Sweeney Todd, The Demon Barber of Fleet Street, by Christopher Bond. It recounts the sinister tale of Benjamin Barker, who is unjustly transported for life by the corrupt Judge Turpin. Upon returning home after fifteen years, Barker takes the alias Sweeney Todd and, when revenge on Turpin momentarily evades him, takes out his hatred on his unsuspecting customers, who are murdered and sold in Mrs Lovett’s pie shop.

The dramatic opening certainly caught the audience’s attention. The realisation of Sondheim’s formidable musical arrangement, with its intricate harmonies, is a huge accomplishment which testifies to the diligence and perseverance of both the chorus and the band, under Musical Director Alex Bromwich. However, throughout the show the music was slightly too loud and sometimes even drowned out the singing, a complaint I heard repeated by other members of the audience.

The highlight of the show was Matthew Green’s portrayal of Sweeney Todd, a difficult and yet obviously critical role which he undertook while also directing the production. Despite having to take on the responsibility of directing part way through rehearsals, Green makes skilful artistic choices, particularly in the strong and memorable epilogue. Green was also able to meet the vocal and dramatic demands of playing the eponymous character; his excellent voice was well suited to the role and he managed to get into the twisted mind of this disturbing man.

The most exceptional scenes in the play were the duets by Green and co-star Eleanor George, who played Mrs Lovett, specifically ‘A Little Priest’ and ‘By The Sea’. They took great advantage of the comedic elements of these scenes, getting the timing perfect, which lent a lighter tone to an otherwise extremely dark musical. The pair had great chemistry and nailed the demanding vocals of their duets. George re-created Mrs Lovett’s highly amusing persona well and maintained it throughout the entirety of her performance, including the accent.

The debut performance of Lotte Jones showed great potential in her role as the pure and lovely Johanna, to which her beautiful voice was perfectly suited. Yet while she managed the difficult vocals in her solo ‘Green Finch and the Linnet Bird’, it could have been improved by clearer diction. Anthony Pengelly, in the role of Johanna’s love interest Anthony, also had an excellent voice – one of the clearest in the cast. While others sometimes mumbled certain lines he always maintained perfect clarity.

Also commendable was Callum Miller in the role of Judge Turpin, whose simultaneous perversion and vulnerability he managed to capture well. Likewise, Stephanie Peacock effectively depicted the insanity of the beggar woman, though her wonderful voice seemed slightly wasted on a secondary role. Daniel Mayfield clearly tried hard to depict the little boy Toby, but it was difficult to imagine him in this role due to his height; an unavoidable problem when student productions contain children. It was also hard to understand him at times due to his low volume and mumbling of certain parts.

Furthermore, the bare and simple set design was completely suited to a musical in which the performances of the cast should be the main focus rather than their surroundings and the two level staging created an interesting dynamic. However, it was difficult to see any action that occurred on the lower level of the stage even from the middle of the audience. Moreover, crucial parts of the show were inaudible due to microphone problems. Certain actors, notably Eleanor George and Daniel Mayfield, had recurring microphone issues which were rather detrimental to their performances. Whether this was down to problems with the equipment, or perhaps the actors’ inexperience of using it, I’m sure it can be easily resolved.

Yet despite these minor technical and staging issues, Van Mildert’s production of Sweeney Todd: A Musical Thriller is both a visual and auditory spectacle which is of a high standard for amateur student theatre. It was definitely worth the trip up the hill.

 

Image: Emma Thrower.