Review: Mean Girls (Sunderland Empire)

By Alex Roy

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Sunderland has turned pink for the week as Mean Girls has landed at the Sunderland Empire in all its high-gloss, fetch glory. There is something striking about the arrival of a show like this on tour: a musical so deeply embedded in contemporary pop culture that audiences come with pre-conceived familiarity. We were fortunate enough to be able to review the West End iteration, so revisiting it on tour is very exciting.

Adapted from the 2004 film, Mean Girls has long since transcended its original medium, its lexicon firmly cemented in the everyday. The stage adaptation leans into this legacy while reconfiguring it for theatrical space — expanding its world through choreography, music, and design, whilst retaining the biting self-awareness that made it endure in the first place.

I ought to first and foremost begin with transparency: I saw the West End iteration 13 times over the course of its year-long run. This is a show I know well, and thus a show I love. It is fun, knowingly silly, and structurally precise, built on sharp choreography, soaring belts, and ensemble work that rarely lets the energy falter. Yet, returning to it here, on tour, my intrigue lay less in the material itself and more in its translation — how does a show so reliant on polish, and visual slickness adapt to the demands of touring life?

For the uninitiated, Mean Girls follows teenager Cady Heron as she swaps rural Kenya for North Shore High School in North-Western Illinois, quickly becoming entangled in the politics of teenage cliques — most notably, the reigning trio known as ‘The Plastics’. What unfolds is a familiar yet enduring narrative of identity, assimilation, blossoming love, and the visceral nature of teenage social structures.

Scenic design by Scott Pask instead embraces a more physical theatricality

Where the West End production leaned heavily on digital screens to facilitate slick, almost cinematic transitions, the touring production necessarily pivots. Scenic design by Scott Pask instead embraces a more physical theatricality, utilising a series of flying set pieces to construct the world — from a sun-drenched Kenya to Regina’s saccharine pink bedroom, from the hallways of North Shore High to the Old Orchard Mall. For the most part, this is an ingenious adaptation, preserving the visual language of the show while accommodating the logistical realities of touring.

In Act One, these transitions are impressively seamless, particularly the shift from ‘Apex Predator’ into Regina’s bedroom, which retains both pace and clarity. There is a confidence here in the mechanics of the production. Act Two, however, proves more resistant. With the script offering little leeway for scene changes, the physical set occasionally exposes its own limitations — most notably in moments such as ‘Whose House Is This?’, where the persistent presence of the North Shore scenery slightly disrupts the internal logic of the scene. It is not a fatal flaw, but it is one that momentarily fractures the otherwise cohesive world.

Yet, the heart of Mean Girls remains resolutely intact. The book by Tina Fey is as sharp and self-aware as ever, its humour landing with an ease that speaks to its longevity. Karen’s earnest “can I still have two?” continues to draw laughter, while Cady’s awkward attempts at social navigation retain their endearing discomfort. It is a text that understands itself and, crucially, understands its audience.

Musically, the production remains a juggernaut

Musically, the production remains a juggernaut both in its lyrics by Nell Benjamin and orchestrations by John Clancy. Oscillating between pop and more traditional musical theatre idioms, the score offers broad appeal without sacrificing character specificity. ‘I’m Blowing Up’, retained from the West End run, proves a standout addition — an undeniable earworm that lingers long after the curtain falls, even if its inclusion comes at the expense of ‘Fearless’. ‘World Burn’ remains an expected high point, but it is Georgie Buckland’s ‘I’d Rather Be Me’ that emerges as the evening’s vocal pinnacle — her riffs are electrifying, and her performance was met with the night’s most emphatic applause.

It is, however, in its performances that this production truly distinguishes itself. Unusually for a press night, audiences were treated to a number of covers and debuts; this injected a palpable sense of energy into the evening.

Leading the charge, first cover Regina George Lillia Squires delivered a poised and commanding performance, underpinned by formidable vocal strength. Her Regina is controlled, calculated, and menacing — charting the character’s rise and fall with precision. Alongside her, Rebekah Bryant, making her debut as Karen, offered a performance that already rich with comedic instinct. Her ‘Sexy’ is gorgeously delivered, and her ‘Whose House Is This?’ lands with confident humour; one senses this is a performance that will only grow with time.

Kiara Dario’s Gretchen is sharply observed, her frantic energy undercut by a genuine emotional fragility that elevates ‘What’s Wrong With Me?’ beyond caricature. Emily Lane’s Cady, meanwhile, is among the most assured I have seen. Her vocal clarity and emotional trajectory mapping the character’s journey with precision, from outsider to Plastic and, ultimately, to something more grounded.

Max Gill and Georgie Buckland as Damien and Janis are standout presences

Max Gill and Georgie Buckland as Damien and Janis are standout presences, their chemistry lending a sense of spontaneity and depth to every shared moment. Gill retains Damien’s comedic flamboyance while showcasing impressive vocal control, while Buckland’s Janis is particularly striking – her performance grounded in a tangible anger that lends weight to the character’s relationships and motivations.

A notable mention must also go to Stefanos Petri, who makes a confident and charismatic debut as Kevin G, navigating both comedy and musicality with ease, particularly in the Mathletes sequences.

Faye Tozer’s multi-rolling across the adult women is, in many ways, a study in contrast. In the more exaggerated roles (Ms Heron and Mrs George) her performance is assured and effective, drawing significant laughter from the audience. It is in such exaggeration that she thrives (I have seen her excel in a panto setting). However, her Ms Norbury feels less settled, with moments of uncertainty through line-stumbles and a slightly muted physicality. While Tozer brings undeniable presence (and I aim not to negate her extensive theatre credits), it does raise broader questions around stunt casting — not as an inherent flaw, but as a practice that can, at times, sit in tension with the precision demanded by a production of this scale.

As a collective, however, the ensemble is nothing short of electric. The precision of ‘Where Do You Belong?’ is among the sharpest I have seen, its choreography executed with clarity and intent. The ensemble work throughout is dynamic and detailed, each performer contributing to a world that feels consistently alive. Particular credit must go to Charlotte Pourret, whose commitment to every moment — especially within the show’s more heightened choreography — proves consistently scene-stealing, her “coochie slams” evoking raucous laughter.

In a touring context, direction becomes all the more visible, and all the more impressive. Casey Nicholaw’s direction and choreography navigate multiple intersecting character arcs with remarkable fluidity, balancing spectacle with nuance, and comedy with emotional clarity.

Ultimately, while certain technical limitations are inevitably felt in the transition from West End to tour, Mean Girls remains a production that understands exactly what it is — and exactly what it offers. It is sharp, self-aware, and unashamedly entertaining. More than that, it is a show that continues to find new life in each iteration, proving that its appeal is not confined to a single space or scale. Here, on tour, it remains as fetch as ever.

Image: Paul Coltas