Review: Fresh

By Orán McNally

*This article contains spoilers*

Reader be warned, Mimi Cave’s directorial debut Fresh stars Normal People’s Daisy Edgar-Jones and Sebastian Stan of MCU and Pam & Tommy fame in a bizarre black comedy thriller that requires a strong stomach.

The film begins with Noa (Edgar-Jones), a young woman who has grown sick of the modern dating scene but is willing to give it one last go after agreeing to meet with Chad. Unfortunately, Chad turns out to be a gas-lighting chauvinist and Noa throws in the towel. That is until she meets Steve (Stan) in the supermarket who charms her with his down-to-earth old-fashioned demeanour. The pair immediately hit it off and after several dates Steve suggests they go on a trip. Admittedly, having started the film with no idea what to expect, I was groaning at the thought that I was about to commit myself to two hours of a somewhat heavy-handed romcom — I couldn’t have been more wrong. Starting as all nightmares do, Steve says that they need to stay at his for a night before heading on their trip. Upon arriving at his forest getaway Steve mixes up a cocktail and Noa drinks it before falling unconscious.

The viewer is caught between not being able to watch whilst also not being able to take their eyes off the screen

Roll the opening credits.

Noa awakens in chains with Steve watching from the other side of the room. To her horror, Steve reveals his true intentions. Spoiler alert: he tells her that he harvests the body parts of women and sells them to mysterious and wealthy clientele who then eat the flesh. Not long after, we see Steve dance around his kitchen to Animotion’s ‘Obsession’ as he slices a leg apart. The atmosphere of the film is dominated by the alarming cognitive dissonance between the masterfully curated 80s-era soundtrack and the deranged Steve butchering various parts of the female anatomy. The viewer is caught between not being able to watch whilst also not being able to take their eyes off the screen.

The film manifests the horrors of modern dating for women into a literal butcher shop and does so in a horrifically unsettling though all the same enthralling way. The presentation of what have now become admittedly romcom tropes such as the mysterious guy not having any social media that are seen pre-title sequence serve to fortify the illusion that Steve is selling. Noa’s attraction to him is largely built out of the idea that he, too, is disillusioned with online dating and that he’s a down-to-earth guy who prefers meeting people the old-fashioned way. All of this to disguise his terrifyingly sinister motives.

The narrative handles female resistance in an interesting way

The narrative handles female resistance in an interesting way as we see Noa manipulate Steve just as he did to her and gains his trust by presenting herself as likeminded. Steve’s prior notion that no one else understands his fascination and that he’s alone in this existence is what Noa uses to her advantage.

Sebastian Stan’s performance is possibly the one that shines through the most in this dark comedy. Switching from the guy-next-door to a lunatic who dances and sings as he butchers human flesh, to a screaming dominating captor, is a stark departure from his most well-known portrayal of Bucky Barnes. However, admittedly some of the lunacy feels in a similar vein to his take on Tommy Lee in Pam & Tommy — yes, I’m thinking of that scene.

Daisy Edgar-Jones also proves herself to be a diverse and talented actor. The worry that she would be playing an American Marianne is the pitfall the film wants you to fall into in the beginning. Showing a great capacity for emotional range, it was thoroughly entertaining to see her take on a ‘final girl’ type role.

Fresh is definitely one for the must-watch list that came seemingly out of nowhere. With a fever dream editing style, unforgiving gore, a soundtrack for the ages, and striking performances by the two leads, the film is a truly cinematic experience that leaves me excited to see what Mimi Cave does next.

Image: Jeremy Yap via Unsplash