Review: Eat My Heart Out
By Kate Wilkinson
Last term I attended a talk, hosted by the University College Feminists, with the writer Zoe Pilger who discussed her debut novel Eat My Heart Out, read a few extracts and answered questions. My interest was won and I left keen to read the novel in full.
Though the evening was held in the grandiose Senate Suite of University College I was briefly transported out of comfortable, conventional, homogenous Durham and into a world of, well, something else.
Eat My Heart Out follows the wilful and wayward protagonist, twenty-three-year-old Ann-Marie, as she veers from one mad experience to the next. After a calamitous break-up and failed degree at Cambridge, Ann-Marie lives an unsteady life in London to say the least. Often she seems to be bound up in an obsessive drive to find her own path through life (her Skype username is ‘purposedestiny7’). This drive revolves around romance and she has a tendency to throw herself at men, quite literally.
Often, however, Ann-Marie finds herself the victim of circumstance and the progression from one event to another appears random and chaotic. Her life becomes all the more complicated when she becomes the protégée of a radical second-wave feminist called Stephanie Haight. It gradually becomes clear that Stephanie is just as troubled as Ann-Marie and the fraught and problematic relationship between these two characters reveals a disconnect between the generations.
My sketchy narrative arc does very little justice to the experience of reading the novel which could be said to be just as much about the narcissistic hedonistic London in which Ann-Marie lives, as about the protagonist herself. The satire explores some of the most extreme excesses of human behaviour which is framed by such banal surroundings and spare narration that by the end it all starts to become worryingly normal.
The novel is full of ideas – whether they are taken from direct experience or quoted from a book that Ann-Marie is reading- but due to the satirical tone it is impossible to privilege any particular view-point. Many issues are raised but no answers are given. The novel may be full of feminist theory but it doesn’t follow a political agenda.
Pilger looks at issues of romance, sex, power relations and aggression through the variety of relationships on display. Sadomasochistic undertones pervade almost every relationship in the novel, including those that are not explicitly sexual. Ann-Marie’s housemate Freddie has a boyfriend who relates how being kicked in the face by Freddie as a school-boy coincided with them falling in love. This sort of experience recurs throughout the novel, and provides interesting insight into the very nature of human relationships.
Before we get too deep, it is important to remember that this is a satire and Pilger balances darkness with a casual tone and frequent laugh-out-loud moments.
Eat My Heart Out ends rather uncertainly, which I suppose fits Ann-Marie’s uncertain nature. Nevertheless, I did finish the novel blinking to myself, wondering what to make of it. Though part of me might have sought for a little more direction as to what to think, the open-endedness is really the novel’s main strength.
Pilger has been described as London’s Lena Dunham and her writing does feel of-the-moment in a similar way. Her multifarious depiction of urban life in what is described on the blurb as our ‘post-post-feminist era’ provides much to think about. In an interview with the Guardian she said “I think the effects of [our] supposedly permissive culture have been really under-examined”. In Eat My Heart Out Pilger explores and examines her concerns while providing an entertaining if somewhat unsettling read.
Photograph: Rebecca Duke, courtesy of University College Feminists

