Review: …Earnest? (UK Tour)

By Alex Roy

Rating: 5 out of 5.

What happens when the leading performer in a production of The Importance of Being Earnest doesn’t show up? …Earnest?, the latest offering from Say It Again, Sorry? theatre company answers that question in a way which is, to put it bluntly, bonkers. The result is a night of chaos, comedy, and theatrical brilliance.

In the first ten minutes or so, the production appears to be a conventional staging of Wilde’s novel. However, when the actor playing Earnest fails to appear, the ‘director’ (Josh Haberfield) has no choice but to recruit an unsuspecting audience member for the role. Thereon, chaos ensues in the most flamboyant manner possible. Reminiscent of Noises Off and The Play That Goes Wrong, this show is a masterclass in controlled disorder, where the plot – loosely tethered to Wilde’s original – becomes secondary to the sheer comedic gold of the concept itself.

The script, or what remains of it, allows for spontaneity while ensuring the show isn’t completely derailed

This ingenious concept is the work of writer Josh King, brought to life under the impeccable direction of Simon Paris. The concept-actors gradually dropping out and being replaced by audience members is as risky as it is brilliant. Yet, thanks to the carefully constructed framework, that which could easily descend into disarray is instead a hilariously executed piece of improvised theatre. The script, or what remains of it, allows for spontaneity while ensuring the show isn’t completely derailed. This balancing act is a testament to both the skill of the cast, who subtly guide the action while embracing the unpredictability of each night’s performance, as well as the genius of the writing itself.

The professional cast is nothing short of exceptional, with standout performances from Josh Haberfield as Simon Slough, Ben Mann as Josh, and Rhys Tees as Graham. Haberfield, in the role of the ‘director,’ is the anchor of the production, orchestrating much of the mayhem while delivering perfectly timed comedic interjections. His running commentary, whether selecting audience members or giving hilarious acting notes (“keep it naturalistic”), ensures the madness feels strangely coherent. Ben Mann, embodying a jittery, hapless stagehand, provides some of the show’s most laugh-out-loud moments. A highlight was his interval performance, where he attempted to sell merchandise and, at the audience’s prompting, removed his top to boost tote bag sales – a moment as whacky as it was genius.

Finally, and more in tune with conventional acting praises, is Rhys Tees, taking on a handful of roles. From a convincingly poised Lane in the opening scene to an increasingly frazzled performer once the crisis unfolds, his ability to shift between characters is impressive. The highlight of his performance comes when he voices the roles of both the Reverend and Miss Prism – characters played by audience members, dictated by his voice. His ad-libs, perfectly in sync with their unscripted actions, had the audience in absolute stitches.

Comedy permeates each and every aspect of this production, from the script’s playful improvisation to its inspired use of props

Comedy permeates each and every aspect of this production, from the script’s playful improvisation to its inspired use of props. The audience script, for instance, becomes a recurring comedic device – sometimes misplaced, sometimes entirely absent, even in one moment replaced with a Harry Potter script (leading to the unforgettable moment where Earnest recites Emma Watson’s famous “I’m going to bed…” line). These meta-theatrical flourishes serve not only to amplify the humour but also to affirm the genius of the concept itself, with the audience relishing in the comedy related to participation.

Of course, as per the promotional tagline, this is the show which makes the audience the stars. Audience participation can often be a nerve-wracking prospect, but …Earnest? handles it delicately. Participation is encouraged but never forced, ensuring those who take the stage are wholeheartedly keen. At my performance, Earnest was played by Marta, a particularly eager audience member, leading to a delightfully gender-bent take on Wilde’s leading man. Following this casting, the entire night featured a gender-bent cast, from a male Cecily and Gwendolen to a female Reverend, only heightening the bonkers absurdity. The love scenes took on a newfound, gloriously queer hilarity, and the sheer unpredictability of watching non-actors embody these roles made for some truly joyous moments.

A final note must go to the sheer brilliance of …Earnest?’s programme. Without giving too much away, it is reversible – one side featuring the ‘real’ production details, and the other an in-universe programme for the fictional, doomed performance. This level of attention to detail exemplifies the production’s commitment to its meta-theatrical premise.

…Earnest? is unlike anything I have ever seen before. For two hours, I was swept up in the madness of Wilde’s play, albeit in a totally unrecognisable manner. If you enjoy improvisation, one-liners, and a touch of theatrical mayhem, you must see this show.

…Earnest? is in performance at the Darlington Hippodrome until Tuesday, 11th March 2025, before continuing on a UK Tour. Tour dates and tickets can be found here.

Image Credit: Mark Senior