Review: Pride and Prejudice* (*Sort of)

By Alex Roy

Rating: 5 out of 5.

‘It is a truth universally acknowledged’ that Pride and Prejudice* (*Sort of) is a sparkling addition to the contemporary musical theatre scene, cleverly blending history with brash modernity, biting humour, and hilarious self-awareness. I believe that good musical theatre can exist in two spheres: the first is emotional depth, theatrical grandeur, and high production value, leaving audiences moved by the sheer scale of artistry such as those like Hamilton or Les Misérables. The second sphere leans into its own absurdity, inviting audiences to abandon the outside world, instead welcoming laughter, silliness, and pure joy – this describes Pride and Prejudice* (*Sort of) perfectly. 

The musical reimagines Jane Austen’s classic novel, telling the story through the eyes of the servants of the Bennet household. With an abundance of disco balls, gender-bending, outlandish profanity, and karaoke, this production defies the conventions of both Austen’s world and typical theatre, instead opting for a resonant hilarity. This historical conceptualisation of musicals is no stranger to the modern theatre scene with Six, &Juliet, and Suffs. In this way, Pride and Prejudice* (*Sort of) adds to this canon, adding a particular edge that appeals greatly to a British and regional audience.

The music in this production does not position itself as a rival to the quality of the narrative but instead serves to amplify the comedic nature of the show. Confusingly, the music of jukebox musicals – despite being integral to their name – can be a pitfall of such shows, particularly when they are inherently serious, or moving shows. Such serious themes can often be undermined by song choices that fail to reflect the tone of the scene or production. In total contrast to this, Pride and Prejudice* (*Sort of) is a show that works perfectly under the guise of the ‘Jukebox’ label, with the songs adding an unserious joy that works seamlessly with the unashamedly gleeful tone of the show.

The synergy of the cast made the small ensemble feel well-rounded and dynamically connected – a crucial element in such an intimately laughter-driven show

The versatility of the cast is remarkable, with Naomi Preston Low, as Elizabeth Bennet, standing out. Working under the clever direction of Isobel MacArthur, Preston Low steals scenes with her warmth and wit, blending comedy with emotional depth – particularly in Act 2. Rhianna McGreevy’s alternating roles as Mrs Bennett and Darcy were equally well-timed, showcasing impressive transformations. The synergy of the cast made the small ensemble feel well-rounded and dynamically connected – a crucial element in such an intimately laughter-driven show. 

Having seen the production’s groundbreaking West End run in 2021, I had the unique experience of being able to watch this touring production comparatively. One notable change that left me slightly underwhelmed was the shift from a set filled with real books to a 2D, book-patterned wallpaper. At the Criterion Theatre, the abundance of physical books created an immersive, meta ‘book world’, continually contextualising the story. While I recognise and understand the adjustment easing the logistics of touring, it felt like a small step back in creating a layered, literary atmosphere. One set adjustment I was delighted about, however, was the reimagining of the staircase. The former, rather impractical, winding staircase had been replaced with a balcony staircase, which effectively utilised the stage space to add authenticity to the Bennet household being portrayed. This design change lends greater depth to the set, facilitating some delightfully humorous entrances and musical moments. 

It was interesting to note the reception of the production. This show, utilising a story with which many are familiar, combining it with some vulgar humour, popular songs, and a self-aware nod to the ridiculous nature of the concept, landed incredibly well with the audience in York; the audience responded consistently with unabashed delight. Pride and Prejudice* (*Sort of) is not a show aiming for the subtlety or depth like that which is found in the original novel: it is, instead, a truly joyous celebration that transforms Austen’s work into a vibrantly accessible piece of theatre. This, in itself, is an impressive feat: a beloved story made fresh, fun, and unforgettable.

Pride and Prejudice* (*Sort of) is currently on a UK Tour until June 2025. Buy your tickets here. 

Image Credit: Alex Roy