Review: Durham University Choral Society’s ‘Dona nobis pacem’ at Newcastle Cathedral

By Wilf Morris

A choral work is often felt to be best suited for performance within a site of historical and religious significance, and DUCS’ concert at Newcastle Cathedral is no exception. With refreshments provided by the Friends of St Nicholas, accompanied by an incredibly detailed and comprehensive programme, the stage was set for an evening of entertainment containing two of the most exciting choral works of the 20th century.

The first work to be performed, Francis Poulenc’s Gloria, began with a delightful first movement in which a perfectly balanced choir and wonderful accompanying orchestra (containing a selection of professional players as well as Durham students) thoroughly shined. This was further felt as the choir faithfully interpreted Poulenc’s playful character throughout the third, fourth, and fifth movements, before closing with the solemn yet undeniably moving and introspective character of the final sixth movement. Soprano Mathilde Brun gave a rendition of ‘Qui sedes ad dexteram Patris’ that was at once joyous and reflective, with the final repeated refrains of ‘Amen’ in antiphony between soloist and choir ending Poulenc’s masterwork with a deeply moving and lasting spiritual impression. This was felt clearly throughout much of the audience as a moment of quiet spread throughout the room – before being of course followed by emphatic applause.

At once joyous and reflective, with the final repeated refrains of ‘Amen’ in antiphony between soloist and choir ending Poulenc’s masterwork with a deeply moving and lasting spiritual impression

Following a 20-minute intermission, the ultimate work of the concert was Vaughan Williams’ epic Donna nobis pacem. This commenced with the scriptural first movement ‘Domine Deus, Agnus Dei’, which established the titular refrain of the work, being reiterated by the fantastic soprano at key moments throughout. Surprisingly, this traditional cantata opening is followed by movements which adapt the secular poetry of Walt Whitman, a favourite of Vaughan Williams (who also used Whitman’s verse in his fantastic ‘Sea Symphony’). This, though radical, is a creative choice that was made convincing through the explosive energy of the second movement. The addictive refrain of ‘Beat! Beat! Drums! – Blow! Bugles! Blow!’, convincingly expressed through the intensity of a choir expertly led by Principal Conductor Tim Burke, markedly caused an atmosphere of excitement to buzz throughout the audience.

The central theme of Vaughan Williams’ work – the horrors of war and a desperate plea for peace – are nonetheless sufficiently expressed by the following movements. Vaughan Williams’ uses the format of a religious cantata as an urgent call to peace; this is a sentiment expressed beautifully and eloquently through Baritone Samuel Davie’s haunting iteration of the third movement ‘Reconciliation’, as he brought to life Whitman’s verse in a tone of lamentation, echoed by the successive repetitions of the choir. The scriptural content of the opening is returned to, however, in the composition’s closing movement ‘O Man Greatly Beloved’: the urgent, pleading passage of ‘nation shall not lift up a sword against nation, neither shall they learn war any more / and none shall make them afraid’ was iterated in deeply emotional and overlapping waves of singing from the choir, as both voice and instrument built towards a finale that was heightened in intensity by the acoustics of the cathedral. Finally, the work ended as it was begun, as Mathilde Brun iterated one last time the refrain of ‘Donna nobis pacem’ (Give us peace), closing the work in haunting and contemplative cadence.

An unequivocal success, interpreting faithfully some of the most significant religious choral works of recent times

Durham University Choral Society’s premier concert of Michaelmas Term was an unequivocal success, interpreting faithfully some of the most significant religious choral works of recent times. This was a success made possible by the combined efforts of the harmonious choir, the complementary orchestra, the perfect performances by both Baritone and Soprano soloists, which, under the direction of a precise conductor, produced a thoroughly successful night of music in an epic and grandiose space.

Featured image: Durham University Choral Society