Review: Dunelm Consort & Players: Handel’s ‘Messiah’

By Dan Hicks

Mince pies, mulled wine, mistletoe – and Messiah. For countless choirs and concert-goers across the country, George Frideric Handel’s most famous oratorio is a natural addition to this list of festive fixtures, a treasured musical tradition without which the Christmas season would not be complete. What a delight, then, that the sole performance of Messiah in Durham this December proves to be nothing short of spectacular – and more delightful still that this performance, marked by such polish and professionalism throughout, is mounted and performed almost entirely by students.

Like a phoenix rising from the ashes, the Dunelm Consort & Players (the university’s early music specialists) make a triumphant return to the Durham music scene, delivering a self-assured and stylish concert to a capacity audience in Durham town hall. In programming such a lengthy and well-known work, Dunelm has wisely taken the decision to engage a professional conductor in the form of Daniel Cook, by day the Master of the Choristers and Organist at Durham Cathedral, whose energetic and exuberant presence at the podium drives the music forward with vivacity and verve – but really only enhances the impression that one is witnessing performances of a professional standard.

To open a performance of any kind as a soloist is a particular kind of daunting, particularly with music as familiar as Comfort ye and Ev’ry valley, but after an overture laden with anticipation, tenor Tom Klafkowski left us in no doubt that, much as in the Isaiah text he sang, we were in safe hands and everything was going to be alright. With effortless presence and a lightness of touch which belied the challenges of the passagework, Klafkowski formed one half of a pair of faultless solo bookends to the performance which set the standard for the evening – the other being baritone Samuel Davie, whose robust rendition of The trumpet shall sound (incisively accompanied by Tom Parker on the titular trumpet) had us convinced that the dead would indeed be raised by his stentorian clarion call. In sharp contrast (of mood, rather than quality), sopranos Kate Ryan and Beth Yates each held the audience spellbound with two of Messiah’s stiller movements (How beautiful are the feet and I know that my Redeemer liveth, respectively), delivering with resonance and richness of tone across the range of their arias, and maintaining an immaculate sense of line and lyricism as they launched themselves (and us) into the firmament. 

With the various arias and recitatives divided between a stellar lineup of fifteen soloists (the majority of whom also formed the bulk of the chorus), a review extolling each of them individually would stretch to an unpublishable length – yet time and again I found myself impressed by not only the virtuosic vocal talent on display but also the soloists’ carefully considered approach to texts which too often are deprived of meaning when performed by professionals for whom that year’s Messiah is just one of many. Whether in the serene security of George Daniel’s stratospheric soprano in Rejoice greatly, O daughter of Zion, tenor Matt Holloway-Strong’s vehemently mesmeric melisma in Thou shalt break them, or the sonorous sorrowfulness of alto Ella McAvoy’s He was despised, it was clear that the soloists had engaged with the words as well as the notes – and their performances were the more powerful and affecting for it. Even, and perhaps especially, those with comparatively little time in the spotlight were no less able to grab the attention of the audience: Elliot Gregg (tenor) and Fabian Tindale Geere (bass) were two such, who delivered their respective recitatives with poise and panache.

Yet for all the plaudits one could throw at the feet of any single soloist, it is the collective sound of the ensemble that really clinches this concert. The orchestra, agile and attentive to the singers under Cook’s direction, are largely indistinguishable from a professional outfit – although I doubt there will be many other Messiah performances this year that can boast a theorbo (bass lute), among their ranks, provided and played here by a university Music Department academic. On the handful of fleeting occasions that the orchestra became disconnected from the chorus, order was quickly and smoothly restored by the three students making up the basso continuo: Ted O’Hare (harpsichord), Hugh Clist-Woodward (organ) and Lexi Dunley (cello), whose steady, sensitive accompaniment underpins the entire oratorio and earns them particular praise here.

The effortlessness of the chorus’ collective vocal dexterity through the oratorio’s most intricate passages is, at times, nothing short of breathtaking (particularly considering the breakneck tempi of certain movements!), and the blend achieved within and across the different voice parts is equally impressive – with only the barest hint of the inevitable overexcitement which comes with some of Handel’s more raucous moments. Over the course of the evening, the chorus conveyed to the audience the full gamut of human expression, from the exultant (And the glory of the Lord) to the excoriating (And he shall purify), often moving from one to the other with barely a pause for breath (Surely he hath borne our griefs to All we like sheep) – although this level of emotional engagement, impressively sustained for the majority of the concert, waned once or twice in the face of more technically challenging musical moments.

The one emotional constant, however, is the enjoyment evident in the faces and body language of the performers. It is abundantly clear that every single one of them is having an absolute blast – not least Cook himself, whose conspiratorial grin as he gestured for the audience to stand, as per tradition, for the famous Hallelujah Chorus suggested that he was looking forward to it just as much as we were. This was not the last time we were to get to our feet; the standing ovation at the concert’s conclusion was richly deserved and a just reward for such a phenomenal performance. A coruscating Christmas treat, and a superb first outing for the Dunelm Consort & Players this year – let me be the first to say ‘hallelujah’.

Image by Beth Mitton