Review: DDF’s Infestation — a closer look

By Alex Roy

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Presented by Castle Theatre Company, the second show of the Collingwood Arts Centre’s DDF Programme was Gabriella Whittley’s Infestation, sticking with the darker thematic palette of the evening. Rooting itself in traumatic psychological realities, this production was a story about PTSD and the slow corrosion of domestic spaces by such horrors.

The story centres on Dorothy (Sophie Browning), the wife of honourably discharged soldier, James (Tom Castle). Excited about her husband’s return, she is shocked to find that the man who has returned appears not to be the husband she once knew. Fragile and spontaneously aggressive, the horrors of early WW1 have left him shellshocked. Although the story touches on his experience, it is the impact this has on Dorothy, his wife, which ultimately forms the core plot. With the support of her friends, and the experiences of those around her, Dorothy’s actions culminate in the climax of this play, and the unfortunate end of her husband.

From the outset, what struck me most forcefully was the calibre of performance on display

From the outset, what struck me most forcefully was the calibre of performance on display. The set was simple – unobtrusive and almost austere – allowing the emotional labour of the actors to sit firmly at the centre of the production. There were no elaborate visual distractions; instead, we were invited to dwell in kitchens and living rooms that felt intimate rather than expansive. In light of this, the sheer frequency of scene changes felt distracting at times (despite the professionalism of the offstage crew). Perhaps with the utilisation of lighting, for example, a more seamless means of distinguishing between houses could have been achieved. Yet, the simplicity was effective nonetheless; a play so reliant on psychological tension, simplicity spoke volumes over spectacle, this feature being testament to the directive vision of Gabriella Whittley and Emilia Edwards.

Sophie Browning’s Dorothy was delicately, painfully gorgeous. She charted the trajectory of a woman attempting to hold together a life that is quietly unravelling, moving from tender devotion to frantic desperation with impressive control. Her Dorothy begins as composed, almost maternally attentive, but gradually spirals under the weight of James’ deterioration. Browning’s physicality was particularly striking, evidently shifting from bright-eyed composure into a fractured presence. There was a haunting quality to her performance, suffused with the sense that she was constantly awaiting the next emotional explosion of her husband.

Opposite her, Tom Castle delivered what was arguably the most poignant performance of the entire Collingwood DDF programme. His portrayal of James, a man suffering from visceral shellshock, was deeply unsettling. Under the direction of Whittley and Edwards, the materialisation of the trauma was handled with care, manifesting in unpredictability, insular tenderness, and a physical shaking. Several moments saw Castle erupt into guttural screams, invoking the audience in the horrors of it all. His eyes often appeared unfocused, as though perpetually fixed on a battlefield invisible to those around him. The result was a performance that lingered long after the play ended: a portrait of a man fundamentally displaced from his own life.

Jessica Cloake’s Mary provided a compelling counterpoint. Cloake brought an assured theatrical professionalism to the role, grounding Mary in a pragmatic steadiness that contrasted effectively with Dorothy’s emotional volatility. Her scenes carried a quiet authority; she anchored the narrative with subtle strength. Alongside her, Noah James Benson as John offered a similarly controlled performance. Benson navigated the complexities of loyalty, frustration, and moral tension with admirable nuance. Together, Cloake and Benson created a secondary relationship that mirrored and refracted the central marriage, broadening the play’s emotional landscape.

Becca Morran’s versatility deserves particular praise. Tasked with embodying three distinct characters, Morran differentiated each with clarity and confidence. Her portrayal of Helen stood out most vividly. In a production so emotionally dense, such adaptability is no small feat; Morran’s work demonstrated imaginative range.

These spatial dynamics subtly reinforced the central tragedy – that war does not end when soldiers return home; it simply relocates psychologically

In terms of direction, the piece was handled with notable care. The emotional terrain of Infestation is taxing, and yet the interplay between characters felt measured. Moments of heightened confrontation were balanced by stretches of quiet tension, allowing the audience space to breathe — albeit shallowly. The blocking often reinforced the thematic isolation at the heart of the play: characters separated by physical distance even when sharing the same room, conversations delivered across voids rather than across tables. These spatial dynamics subtly reinforced the central tragedy — that war does not end when soldiers return home; it simply relocates psychologically.

Lighting played a significant narrative role, and for the most part did so effectively. Soft washes delineated time and mood, with cooler tones evoking the vulnerability of night-time scenes. However, there were moments where the visual language became slightly muddied. The blue UV-style hues that initially signalled bedtime or moments of psychological intrusion later bled into daytime scenes, creating brief confusion regarding temporal shifts. In a production so reliant on clarity of atmosphere, a more consistent lighting vocabulary would further enhance its polish. These inconsistencies were minor, yet noticeable, particularly when contrasted with the otherwise high level of technical and performative cohesion.

What Infestation ultimately achieves is an emotional immersion. It does not sensationalise trauma; instead, it allows it to seep gradually into the domestic sphere, mirroring the insidious way psychological wounds infiltrate everyday life. The audience is not presented with a singular explosive climax, but rather with a steady accumulation of strain. The tragedy lies not only in what James has endured, but in what Dorothy is forced to endure alongside him – and in the quiet recognition that love is not always sufficient to mend what war has broken.

By the end of the play, the atmosphere in the auditorium felt palpably altered. That lingering silence is perhaps the greatest testament to the work of the cast, crew, and creatives involved. Infestation engaged the full emotional range of its audience, offering performances of a calibre that would not feel out of place beyond student theatre.

Infestation is playing as part of the Collingwood DDF programme until Saturday 21st February. Get your tickets here.

Image: DDF via @durhamdramafestival2026 on Instagram; publicity credited to Robyn Bradbury.