Review: Chicago
By Jordan Harries
Showbiz, sex, scandal, and unexpected comedy genius are all part of the parcel in Hild Bede Theatre’s production of Chicago.
It follows the story of Roxie Hart, who shoots her lover and is jailed, despite the efforts of her hapless husband Amos. To the dismay of fellow inmate and famous vaudevillian Velma Kelly, Roxie steals both her notoriety and her lawyer: corrupt ‘champion of the downtrodden’ Billy Flynn.
The story is a familiar one, so the pressure was on for director Michael McLauchlan to present a fresh and professional interpretation. He delivered.
Unusually for a musical in Durham, for me the men outshone the women.
Michael Yates as Flynn was exceptional, commanding the stage in performance that was superbly confident both vocally and physically. His two crucial numbers, ‘We Both Reached For The Gun’ and ‘Razzle Dazzle’, were the slick and extremely engaging highlights of the show, and it was refreshing to see a male lead completely unafraid to really fill his role.
Harry Adair won the hearts of the audience with his beautifully subtle performance as Amos Hart, managing to pull off sad and lonely without becoming too pathetic. Whoever came up with the spotlight trick as a way into ‘Mr Cellophane’ should be highly praised. Adair’s comic timing and deadpan delivery was showcased to its best.
Lily Drake was well-cast as Mama Morton and stole the stage in every appearance with a consistently mature, confident, and believable performance. She was the strongest all-round female of the evening.
Lydia Feerick (Roxie) is an incredibly watchable actress and has clearly worked hard to ensure consistently strong characterisation. Her physical humour in numbers like ‘We Both Reached For The Gun’ was fantastic and brought a fresh and unexpected element of lovable awkwardness to the character.
Eliza Cummings-Cove’s beautiful voice meant that she absolutely had to have a lead role, but somehow, first night nerves, perhaps, she did not quite fit the character of Velma.
Her acting itself (comic timing and accent consistency especially) was among the strongest on the stage in numbers like ‘I Can’t Do It Alone’, and her vocal solos were effortless, even casual, but Velma’s physical confidence is something she needs to master. A fiercer, sexier approach to numbers like ‘All That Jazz’ would turn a solid performance into an unforgettable one!
Special mention must go to the choreography team, Catherine Wyatt and Katie Petty, for their beautiful work with the entire cast.
The show’s real strengths lay in its ensemble numbers, for which the dancing girls (and boys) were crucial in evoking Chicago’s debauched but intoxicating jazz scene. Rachel Gill and Nia Treherne in particular were mesmerising (and extra credit to Nia for her costume choice, by far the most exciting take on ‘black, sexy’ on stage).
Aside from a few missed lighting cues, which McLauchlan will iron out for sure, the show was wonderfully slick.
Musical greats like ‘Cell Block Tango’ were excellently and daringly done, with a dash of humour that emphasised the strongly satirical point of the entire musical.
On the whole, the cast do not shy away from the magnitude of this production, and their real strength was in the well-executed and nicely-detailed ensemble work. It was absolutely worth the trek there, “he had it coming” will be stuck in your head for days.
Photograph: Rose Innes

