Review: A Street Car Named Desire (Almeida Theatre)

By Katie Trahair-Davies

A Streetcar Named Desire is one of the most culturally enduring and well performing plays to have emerged from the 20thcentury. Furthermore, it is a play that has become known for the consistent excellence of its adaptations and interpretations, leading me to question what Almeida Theatre’s latest production of the play could add to the already impressive Streetcar oeuvre, studded with the likes of Marlon Brando, Vivian Leigh and Gillian Anderson. However, when the production first was open to the public in 2022, critics and the public alike commended Rebecca Fracknell’s directorial vision, leading the performance into a sold-out run at the Almeida. Granted, a lot of the initial hype surrounding this production came from Paul Mescal’s position in the role of Stanley, but the attention slowly started to centre instead around the general brilliance of the entire cast and production itself. So, when it was announced in November of last year that the production was being brought back to the West End in 2025 for a limited run, I went as far as abandoning a lecture midway to secure my place in the hours long online ticket queue. 

Like most English students, Streetcar has long been ingrained in my academic vocabulary, playing a big role in my A level education. Having not touched the play in a direct manner since then, within minutes of the curtains opening I was immediately reminded of just how good Tennessee Williams’ writing is, regardless of the performance. Then for the remainder of the two hours, my focus was completely overwhelmed by the theatrical prowess and magnetising pull of this specific production, made to shine by the design and creative decisions made by Fracknell. Whilst Williams’ artistic talent may be the true bones of greatness that makes almost any rendition of this play such a brilliant piece of theatre, it is undeniable that Fracknell’s directive force brought new life and creativity into the 1947 play – equally giving the homage that the roots of the play deserves, whilst also bringing a vivacity to the story that would appeal more widely to a modern cultural sensibility. 

It is undeniable that Fracknell’s directive force brought new life and creativity into the 1947 play

Furthermore, I do believe that the minimalist set design and aesthetic direction of the production helped to bring the core of the play to the forefront, truly allowing Williams’ words to shine in every moment. Although perhaps imposing in its starkness at first, the set (designed by Madeleine Girling) allows for the brutality of the play’s tale to be highlighted to the audience. Girling’s artistic vision can only be described as ‘electric’, with bright arresting lighting that shifts melodramatically to dim scenes at a moment’s notice, and drums that thunder throughout the entire theatre, bringing a sense of theatrical modernism to the performance. 

However, the original mood of New Orlean’s lively French Quarter that is often considered integral to the meaning of the play is not lost in this modern reimagining. Through the open set design, the actors are able to sit on the sidelines, or even at times circle the stage itself; creating the claustrophobic feel to the action of the play that is essential in replicating the geographical and cultural identity of the story. The flashes of rain highlight the air of humidity, and the cool, blue toned lighting help create an atmosphere of sensual violence and tragedy, perfectly harmonising with the movements and costumes of the cast. Whilst in the first half it felt slightly reductive to the tenor of the play to replace the traditional sensually melancholic jazz background with drums of an almost overwhelming intensity, I thought this musical choice worked better as the tensions of the play increased in the second half. The drums came to represent for me the headache like tension that one feels whilst watching all the characters clash with increasing ferocity; symbolising the quickening approach of Blanche’s tragic fate, Stanley’s growing anger and violence, Stella’s helplessness and the inevitable moment where Mitch discovers the truth. 

Once again, the actors’ performances struck a balance between truthful homage to the original characters of the play, but with a modern bite

Although due to his prior success it is Paul Mescal who has gained considerable media attention for his role in this adaptation, each and every lead character competed with him for excellence, resulting in an array of performances that truly brought to life William’s characters. Once again, the actors’ performances struck a balance between truthful homage to the original characters of the play, but with a modern bite that I felt brought them relevance within the audience. Perhaps superficially on my behalf (or due to the handful of past productions that formed my perception of the play), the character of Blanche had become associated with a blonde head of hair and visible middling age, so it took me a minute to adjust to Patsy Ferran’s brunette and more youthful performance. However, once I got past these small preconceptions of mine, Ferran’s performance was the highlight of my experience; with each line spoken perfectly capturing the multitude of emotions and contradictions that Blanche is supposed to exhibit. 

The intimacy and intensity of Almedia’s production successfully makes you feel that you too are rattling on this tragedy-struck streetcar, hurtling along defencelessly towards whatever merciless fate Williams has in store for us all. So, when the doctor arrives two hours later to take Blanche, a broken woman, away, I felt both the true pain of her character, and also a dim sense of relief that the building tensions wrought from two hours of thudding drums, dramatic lighting and emotional anxieties could at last be put to rest. This is exactly how I believe one should feel after the showing of such an intensely charged story; there is no moment of exact resolution or redemption for any character, yet the time has come to leave this nerve-fraying world behind to self-implode. The way in which Fracknell staged these last moments represented this feeling perfectly: there was a sense of crescendo that unified both the character narratives and the artistic elements of the production. If at first I was unconvinced by the experimental elements of the production, by the play’s conclusion they all made perfect sense in my head; capturing the very beating heart of this tale in a modern twist that is neither out of place, nor ‘trying too hard’. Almeida’s adaptation manages to find the perfect balance between tradition and modernity. 

Image credit: Marc Brenner