Repealing the Eighth? Ireland’s journey to legal abortion

By Ellen Gribben

Every year thousands of girls and women from the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland will take an exhausting and often lonely journey across the Irish Sea to England, Scotland and Wales. It isn’t tourism or seeing relatives which motivates this particular mass of people to travel to Great Britain. Rather these girls and women travel in order to obtain safe and legal terminations of their unplanned pregnancies.

As an island, Ireland remains partitioned and divided by a border which was ratified by the 1921 Government of Ireland Act. Nonetheless, both Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland remain united by their equally stringent, restrictive and utterly archaic reproductive legislation. In both states abortions are only approved within the realm of rarity. That is, only when a woman’s life is at an imminent and unavoidable risk can abortion be considered. This consideration and subsequent approval rests on the opinions of medical professionals and is only granted in extraordinary circumstances. Plainly speaking, reproductive legislation North and South of the border give equal protection of life for both the unborn child and the mother.

Unplanned pregnancies that emerge from rape, incest or fatal foetal abnormality are not deemed as viable circumstances for a termination. Women and girls who seek an abortion are liable to criminal prosecution in Northern Ireland under the Offences Against the Person Act (1861) and in the Republic of Ireland under the Eighth Amendment of the Constitution Act (1983.) The nature of abortion legislation North and South of the border is reflective of the power and precedence the population places on Christian morality despite the fact the Church attendance has been declining annually at steady rate. Both the Catholic Church and the major Protestant denominations along with the various pro-life groups remain active and vocal critics of any amendment to current laws. Despite this, the pressure on politicians to liberalise reproductive legislation has grown from members of the public, Amnesty International and the UN Human Rights Committee who have described current abortion law or be ‘discriminatory’ and ‘cruel, inhuman and degrading.’

Last year a woman living in Belfast was given a suspended sentence and consequently a criminal record for procuring abortion pills over the internet and inducing miscarriage. At the time of the abortion the woman in question was 19 years old, without a partner and unable to finance the journey needed to secure a legal termination in Great Britain. As details of the trial became public, a media frenzy followed which resulted in scathing criticisms being made about the morality of this woman by pro-life activists – and equally scathing criticisms attacking current legislation from pro-choice commentators. As desperate and heart wrenching as this incident is, it is neither an isolated nor uncommon phenomenon.

Northern Ireland’s chief paediatric pathologist, Dr Caroline Gannon, resigned last month in protest of current legislation which prohibits individuals carrying a child with a fatal foetal abnormality to receive a termination. Dr Gannon felt unable to continue her role after having to give advice to a couple who travelled to England for a termination when it was discovered that their baby was afflicted by a severe disablement and was likely to die shortly after birth. As the couple wanted their child to receive a post-mortem after the termination, Dr Gannon advised the couple on how to preserve the aborted foetus on their journey home in order for a post-mortem to take place in Northern Ireland. Tragically, this culminated in the remains of the foetus being stored in a cooler-bag on the couple’s return home from England.

Restrictive abortion legislation is also an afflictive force for those living in the South of Ireland who want a termination. In 2012, an Irish woman died in the back of a London taxi hours after receiving an abortion in a clinic in Ealing. Her husband later told the The Irish Times that she had sought an abortion in Dublin after her last pregnancy plagued her health complications and left her with prospect of infertility. Appallingly, the couple did not meet the requirements deemed necessary for the pregnancy to cause infinite threat to the mother’s life when an abortion was requested at a Dublin hospital.

Abortion reform in Northern Ireland remains stagnated as politicians and the Attorney General have failed to agree on any viable amendment to the current legislation. However, the emergence, growth and support for the Repeal the 8th campaign in the Republic of Ireland has provided a beacon of hope to those in favour of abortion reform in the South of Ireland. Partly emanating from the success of last year’s same-sex marriage referendum, the Repeal the 8th movement and the South’s younger generation in general seem increasingly disillusioned with the traditionalists’ – and Catholic Church’s – stance on social issues. Clara, a twenty-two year old student living in Dublin, describes the momentum of the campaign; “personally, I think the current repeal campaign is exciting because its being led by such young, innovative people and it’s great to see such physical action being taken.”

If the Eighth Amendment is repealed in the Republic of Ireland abortions will not be available on demand but rather in the circumstances of rape or fatal foetal abnormality. Nonetheless, the discussion on abortion has begun and real progress has been made already in Republic of Ireland which will undeniably influence the debate in Northern Ireland. Yet it is estimated that twelve women will travel to Great Britain every day to access abortion services. Until fundamental legislative change happens, women will continue to make this lonely, painstaking and often secretive journey across the Irish Sea to acquire an abortion.

 

Image by Sandra via Flickr.