Corporate Bias in Careers Fairs

By Elizabeth MacGowan

Whilst consultancy is not the only career path, this was not made clear at the Careers Fair held in October. The Careers Fair should have been a great opportunity for students to talk face-to-face to employers and to receive all the necessary guidance. Apart from being next to Josephine Butler College, the issue with this fair was that 43% of this guidance came from consultancy and financial firms. What does this say about Durham’s outlook on graduate careers? It confirms many students’ concerns that the university pushes us towards certain sectors. Big names and big money seemed to be the Fair’s focus, with apparently little consideration for those looking for different options.

The sponsor, Teach First, should be wary of putting its name to an event that did not seem to encourage all students to realise their potential. The Careers, Employability and Enterprise Centre asked for companies with graduate vacancies in a wide-range of sectors, most of which were business focussed. The ‘wide range’ of organisations featured only one charity, which itself made up ½ of the public-sector companies. Where were the representatives from the rest of the job market? While Durham offers several fairs throughout October and November, the recently held ‘Careers and Internship Fair’ appeared to be the more well-rounded option among the Business and Finance, STEM and Law fairs, yet those looking for careers in alternative sectors were in danger of feeling like there were no options available.

Most Arts and Humanities students do not take the finance and consultancy paths, and last week felt like another indication that we are being left behind – anyone seen Elvet Riverside lately? Some students naturally feel that their skills are better suited to their degree-related areas, which isn’t always business, finance or STEM related. While it was reassuring to see that your degree does not necessarily set your career path, it was not encouraging to question if your university does.

The CEEC offers a gold mine of advice and support, from individual meetings to CV checks to checking over applications and providing skills workshops, which perhaps is why the apparent bias is surprising. The CEEC’s website does offer great advice for looking at smaller companies, who often don’t have the resources to attend events like Career Fairs but can, the CEEC says, offer more responsibility, progression and less competition when applying. They are willing to help with all career paths yet, when giving blanket advice and suggesting where to apply, they pointed in one direction. While the help is there if you go looking for it, that’s exactly the problem; often we don’t know what we want or how to look for it, which is why the Careers Fair is important in laying out paths and opportunities in front of those who need guidance.

The nature of Careers Fairs push students towards the big names: while it seems like we are being pushed towards these industries, their recruitment is also just the loudest in the crowd. Media and Marketing organisations simply don’t feel the need to come to campus as we will go to them anyway: at least 115 of graduates with first degrees going to Marketing organisations in 2015. Whilst it is easier for the university to attract big companies who spend on recruitment – a likely attraction for high achieving, ambitious students – they do not function to display a ‘breadth of career paths’. The general Careers Fair should be promoted differently to reflect the organisations that attend, and it should be a priority for the CEEC to let us explore all areas of the job market so that they are providing for the diverse qualities that we can offer. Other careers are not alternative, secondary or unpopular options, but real futures and ambitions for talented students.

Still another question springs to mind; is this a move reflecting our own interests? Michaelmas term can often feel like a stress of deadlines and competition, and perhaps we are in danger of following successful friends who can offer advice and contacts. It is easier to take the road well-travelled but it does not reflect well to think that many Durham graduates end up in similar places. Durham graduates cannot reach their full potential or represent the university best by working in specific industries, but instead by working in industries that best suit the individual’s skills. It is also easier to take the option that throws flyers and money at us, but it is evident that if the CEEC is not going to provide us with well-rounded options then we need to look harder.

Consultancy and finance firms are clearly attracted to Durham students and willing to spend big money to charm us, but money should not be a factor for the CEEC when laying out our potential opportunities. Perhaps other employers that are just as eager are just around the corner. For those who want to know all of their options, the CEEC should be doing more to present us with wide-ranging choices to help us make informed decisions, not making decisions for us based on who can pay.

Photograph: Durham Students’ Union