Reflections on modern anti-semitism in wake of the Pittsburgh Synagogue Shooting
By Tom Hartley
“De două mii de ani” – “For two thousand years” wrote Mihail Sebastian in 1934.
On the 27th October 2018 Robert Bowers, “a bearded heavy-set white male”, entered The Tree of Life or L’Simcha Congregation in Pittsburgh, yelled “All Jews must die” and fired indiscriminately into a crowd of over fifty people during their Shabbat (Jewish sabbath) morning service. Eleven innocent people were killed. Even as he was being arrested he remarked to one of the police officers: “all these Jews need to die.”
This tragic event is not about America’s nonsensical firearm policy; this event is not about Trump’s response in which he bemoans the lack of security within the synagogue (“if they had some kind of protection inside the temple, maybe it could have been a very much different situation”); this event isn’t even about Gab, the far right social media platform that Bowers used to spew his violent and hate filled rhetoric. This event is about anti-semitism.
Anti-semitism isn’t a new phenomenon, it didn’t begin on the 27th October 2018, nor in the Camps of Primo Levi and Elie Wiesel. Not in the university of Mihail Sebastian, nor the pogroms of the Tsar. Anti-semitism in all its ugly and senseless guises has been a shameful part of societies for two thousand years. This event, much like many others, is arguably just another chapter of a book that so desperately needs to be thrown away and looked back on with nothing but disgust.
It is foolish and dangerous however, to assume that all anti-jewish action and rhetoric is simply another expression of the ‘eternal anti-semitism’ that Sebastian writes about, as Hannah Arendt states in her important 1951 work “The Origins of Totalitarianism”. Anti-semitism has context and contemporary events shape the forms of persecution that Jews suffer. The resurgence of white nationalism across the western world is a large factor in the increasing amount of and the normalisation of anti-semitic rhetoric.
The special and constant abuse that is reserved only for Jewish billionaire George Soros, in both his birth nation of Hungary and in his adopted home America, is a prime example of this. Viktor Orban, the Hungarian Prime Minister, launched a widespread campaign of billboards with Soros’ name or face prominently displayed in order to stoke anti-immigrant sentiments and pedal his nationalistic agenda, whilst politicians of the GOP accuse Soros of funding the ‘migrant caravan’ making its way through Central America towards the US border.

Example of the Hungarian billboards regarding the “National Consultation” on the Soros Plan. Translation: “About the Soros Plan, let’s not let it happen without a word.”
Donald Trump has recently spoken at length about his wariness towards globalism and globalists, professing to his fans at rallies that he is a proud: ‘nationalist’. When Trump says things such as these, it is crucial to be aware of what it means in regards to anti-semitism. Jewish communities, especially during the early 20th Century, were persecuted as ‘globalists’, as not belonging to a specific nationality and therefore, “undermining good people who are bound to their soil.” Many anti-semitic theories rely on this equivocation between ‘Jew’ and ‘globalist’. To openly insult globalists as the enemy and to even call the Jewish Gary Cohn a globalist, is repetition and normalisation of this anti-semitic trope, this ‘globalist’ charge is also frequently levelled at Soros.
It is important to note that it is not only events such as these that act as causes for serious concern. The demonisation of Soros and the murders in Pittsburgh on their own paint a picture of an increasingly intolerant and anti-semitic environment but, there are countless other events that spread anti-jewish hate on a daily basis left uncovered and ignored. The Anti-Defamation League reported a 57% increase in anti-semitic events in 2017 in the United States, bringing the total number of individual cases to 1,986 and leading to an average of just over 5 anti-semitic incidents daily.
This is particularly alarming to the American Jewish communities because these incidents are occurring in a country that was, in the past, the only refuge for millions of Jews fleeing persecution in Europe. For most of the 20th Century, America was the nation with the highest Jewish population although recently overtaken by Israel. It is not an overstatement to suggest that most of the six million Jews that currently live in the US are likely there because their families historically suffered at the hands of European anti-semitism.
On the 27th October 2018, the Pittsburgh Jewish community lost eleven people. Five of those killed were alive at the time of the Holocaust. Awareness of anti-semitism ultimately isn’t enough; it is not a new phenomenon, it is certainly not something that we should struggle to come to terms with. We’ve seen it before, we’ve seen what it can lead to and we need to actively stop it from prospering.
“Nu pentru încă două mii de anii” – “Not for another two thousand years”
Image by White House photo by Paul Morse via Wiki Commons
