Internet poetry: the death of nuance

By Fergus Burnett-Skelding

Ours is the time to mourn the passing of measured argument. From Trump’s polarisation of a nation to Labour’s internecine issues, public discourse has become a forum for extremes. Worryingly, the literati can no longer provide sanctuary in this ideological war zone. Binary extremism has begun to insinuate itself into literary criticism.

The debate on the latest phenomenon in poetry is illustrative. Published initially on social media – and, having garnered a sufficient following, published in hard copy by canny publishers – internet poetry has produced two critical camps positioned in irrationally diametric opposition.

In the blue corner, a group of critics defer to that well-known yardstick of merit, the approbation of the masses. They proffer the number of ‘likes’ internet poets can muster as absolute proof of artistic talent, and politicise poets by lauding their gender, class, or race, over their literary ability.

Binary extremism has begun to insinuate itself into literary criticism

Rupi Kaur, a 25-year-old Canadian-Punjabi Instagram poet, is a prime beneficiary of these poetic partisans. Kaur’s millions of Instagram followers have seemingly had an amnesic impact on some. By praising Kaur’s attempts to pass her banal views on race, gender, and heartbreak off as universal aphorism, such supporters seem to have forgotten that poetry is the transcription of timeless epiphany, requiring more than unconsidered line breaks or the eschewal of capital letters.

But where is the harm in this flagrant rejection of critical faculties? What is the impact of treating such lines as ‘she was music/but he had his ears cut off’ positively everywhere from Radio 4’s Woman’s Hour to this very paper?

For one, the idea that a legitimate metric for poetic quality is the number of virtual thumbs up it can accrue reveals a worrying paradigm shift amongst this group of critics. Poetry has ceased to be celebrated for the evocative nature of its language or the resonance of its concepts, instead being judged on its ‘accessibility’.

In the age of Twitter and Deliveroo, ‘accessible’ denotes nothing more than an admixture of brevity, simplicity and instant gratification, something that truly great poetry will always struggle to offer. Hardy, Plath, Swinburne and the gang require an investment of time and thought; Kaur’s merry band of sycophants marginalise this truly life-enhancing poetry.

The other harmful consequence is that, as defenders of more traditional poetry inflate with irritation, they abandon balance in their own critique of internet poetry. In order to effectively scupper the rise of the bad, they are indiscriminate in their hatred of it all. These are the occupants of the red corner: suspiciously technophobic writers disavowing the work of anyone who dares be so base as to mix social media and poetry.

Technophobic writers disavow the work of anyone who dare be so base as to mix social media and poetry

These critics portray a serious lack of nuance by lumping very successful poets in with the coterie of woe-is-me solipsists. One such victim is Charly Cox, the author of the collection She Must Be Mad. Published after Cox’s Instagram popularity came to the attention of HarperCollins, her collection is 2018’s best-selling book of poetry. Predominantly focusing on her own mental health, it would be easy to accuse Cox of Kaur-esque self-indulgence. But she is quite different. A plaintive understanding of the irony of modern life permeates her work, and her linguistic dexterity marks her out as worth a read.

As with any sector of literature, it is impossible to paint all internet poets with the same brush. Let us, then, resuscitate failing nuance, and start to winnow the wheaten stanzas from the platitudinous chaff.

Image credits: Google via Creative Commons