Prostitution should be legalised

by Nick Bradley

In the UK, it is estimated that over 100,000 prostitutes are currently working in brothels, massage parlours, and on the streets. Of the estimated 80,000 who work on the streets, 87% are addicted to heroin. Over half have been raped or seriously injured at the hands of their pimps or punters. 92% would escape the sex industry immediately if they could. These figures do not even take into account the incalculable numbers of sex workers who operate from escort sites, online chat-rooms, and by word of mouth. Clearly, business is booming.

The image projected by the figures above is nothing short of tragic. However, there needn’t be an insuperable link between these figures and the sex industry. Tragedy and prostitution needn’t be synonymous.

Unregulated prostitution breeds many problems. For instance, in the USA prostitution is the third most common way to catch AIDS. Roughly half of New York City’s and Washington D.C.’s prostitutes are HIV positive. As well as the health risks, the nature of an unregulated sex industry, the existence of which many wish to deny, makes problems of exploitation, trafficking and wide-scale abuse, highly likely. Legalization will substantially reduce the health risks as well as other damaging consequences of a lawless underground sex industry, as found in the UK.

There is a futility in declaring a ‘war on prostitution’ just as there is a futility in continuing the ‘war on drugs’. These wars cannot be won. Both are expensive and ineffective. It is impossible to close down a market between willing buyers and willing sellers. However, there is a crucial difference between the sex industry and the drug trade: prostitution has the potential for respectability.

Is prostitution becoming socially acceptable?

Increasing numbers of university students in the UK are turning to prostitution as a means of funding their studies. The National Union of Students  has claimed this for some time. For these students, it is a choice; a calculated decision made by intelligent adults. Research published by the University of Kingston in 2010 revealed that 16% of those surveyed would consider working in the sex industry. In essence, is prostitution becoming socially acceptable?

The debate raises another issue: is it a woman’s right to sell her body? As long as sales are conducted in an entirely voluntary and safe environment (something that can only be guaranteed by the force of law), the argument for continual criminalisation is very weak. It is exclusively a moral argument. In 2012, the time has come for the government to abandon its attempts to police personal morality. Might it not be thought shameful for our leaders and politicians to make moral judgements, let alone formulate legislation to impose them?

Consider the Netherlands: the prostitutes of the Red Light District in Amsterdam are self-employed ‘entrepreneurs’. They work legitimately, and without the saddle of terror that weighs down upon the street-walkers of the UK. They are guaranteed identical rights to any other Dutch citizen. They are not afraid to go to the police for fear of arrest as they would be in the UK or the US. In the Netherlands, the industry has long been showing signs of genuine respectability.

It is true that most of the prostitutes of the Red Light District hide their chosen profession from their close friends and relatives. It is also true that most of them do not enjoy their work. But nor do many cleaners, waitresses, office-workers etc. An important difference exists between our society in the UK and societies like those of the Netherlands and Canada. When it comes to the sex industry, British society is marked by fear, hypocrisy and shame. A fear of openness is prevalent in all layers of British society. Hence, many British people sweep the sex industry under the carpet. They look the other way. Yet, as the market demonstrates, they are not averse to paying for sexual services, either on the streets or via the internet.

In the Netherlands, there is a Trade Union for the nation’s prostitutes. In the Netherlands, reality is being confronted head on.