Project chainsaw: Labour’s attack on bureaucracy
By David Fagan
Sir Keir Starmer has announced at a speech in Kingston-Upon-Hull that NHS England, the body managing the NHS alongside the Department for Health and Social Care, will be abolished. The decision forms part of Labour’s broader plans for reform within the Civil Service, due to frustrations with “red tape” and an “industry of checkers and blockers”, hindering project delivery. What are the implications of this move, and does it reflect an ideological attack on state bureaucracy in the vein of Elon Musk’s DOGE?
NHS England was created in 2013 by former Health Secretary Andrew Lansley as part of a series of health reforms during the coalition government. Officially dubbed the “world’s largest quango” (Quasi-Autonomous Non-Governmental Organisation), it is publicly funded but operates independently of government. It shares many of the same responsibilities as the Department for Health and Social Care in the management of the NHS but is not directly accountable to the Health Secretary. While the intention was to allow for more political independence in NHS management, it has faced criticism for unnecessary bureaucracy and a lack of democratic accountability.
Given current Health Secretary Wes Streeting’s agenda for reform of the NHS, NHS England was always a likely target for restructuring. Nonetheless, the decision to abolish the body has come as somewhat of a surprise. The previous plan was for the body to be phased out over 2 years, with its size being halved. Instead, all 13,500 jobs will be affected, with 9,000 cuts and the remaining staff transferring into the Department for Health and Social Care.
In his speech, Sir Keir Starmer framed the decision as both a matter of principle and efficiency
In his speech, Sir Keir Starmer framed the decision as both a matter of principle and efficiency. He emphasised democratic accountability, stating “I’m bringing management of the NHS back into democratic control… back into the heart of government, where it belongs.”. He also defended it as a cost-cutting measure – “I can’t in all honesty explain to the British people why they should spend their money on two layers of bureaucracy”.
The move is just part of a wider ongoing effort by the Labour government to streamline the state. Labour’s manifesto prioritised change and growth, but ministers have reportedly expressed frustration with slow progress and delays in policy implementation. The civil service is currently the largest it has been for decades – its workforce has grown by around 130,000 since Brexit – yet it is failing to deliver the government’s desired change. The Prime Minister described the current situation as a “watchdog state, completely out of whack with the priorities of the British people”, that is both “oversized and underpowered”. However, he stressed that the issue is systemic, deliberately distancing himself from the right-wing claim that the civil service operates as an obstructive ‘blob’, saying “the problem isn’t our fantastic civil servants, it’s the system they’re stuck in”.
Placing the decision to abolish NHS England in broader context, Sir Keir Starmer claimed that “Tough choices won’t just stop there, in this era they will keep on coming”. Chancellor Rachel Reeves has also emphasised the need to cut regulation in driving economic growth across the country. According to sources within Whitehall, each department has been asked to report to Number 10 about the regulatory bodies and quangos they do not believe to be absolutely essential. The government has also signalled a push for digital reform in the civil service, arguing it could save £45 bn annually. 10% of civil servants are set to work in tech or digital roles, and AI will be leveraged to replace civil servants where it could perform their job more effectively. The project has reportedly been internally nicknamed “Project Chainsaw”, suggesting parallels with what is happening in the US with Elon Musk’s DOGE (Department of Government Efficiency).
The Prime Minister highlighted his belief in the power of effective and “active government”
However, the Prime Minister highlighted his belief in the power of effective and “active government” and said, “I’m not interested in ideological arguments about whether it should be bigger or smaller, I simply want it to work”. This sets Labour’s mission apart from DOGE’s techno-libertarian approach to dismantling bureaucracy, which sees government as inherently wasteful and inimical to innovation. Therefore, while the projects may appear structurally similar, they are fundamentally quite different.
Overall, Labour’s “Project Chainsaw” represents a major restructuring of state bureaucracy. Its success depends on whether it can deliver more efficient outcomes without causing too much disruption. The Conservatives have pointed out that since Labour came to power, 27 new quangos or task forces have been established, questioning the consistency of the rhetoric coming from Number 10. Nonetheless, looking ahead the British State seems poised for a makeover driven by technological innovation and structural reforms, with AI and efficiency at its core.
Image credit: Simon Dawson, No 10 Downing Street via Wikimedia Commons

