Badenoch Struggles Through PMQs

By David Fagan

Leading a weakened Conservative Party into opposition after fourteen years of government was never going to be easy. More than 100 days into her leadership, Kemi Badenoch is facing increased scrutiny after a series of poor performances at Prime Minister’s Questions.

PMQs is an opportunity for Ms Badenoch to challenge Sir Keir Starmer by raising policy issues, exploiting his weaknesses and positioning her party as a credible alternative. A strong performance can showcase competence and leadership in the eyes of the media, but so far, she has struggled to make an impact at the dispatch box.  

A strong performance can showcase competence and leadership in the eyes of the media, but so far, she has struggled to make an impact at the dispatch box

Starmer is currently far from popular, with a recent Ipsos poll finding that 48% of Britons think he is doing a bad job. Labour’s “necessary but tough decisions”, absent from their manifesto, have already alienated key voter groups such as farmers, students and pensioners. Coupled with the Prime Minister’s glaring lack of charisma, it is particularly surprising that he has recently emerged as the obvious victor at PMQs. This has intensified criticism of Badenoch’s leadership. Are her struggles indicative of deeper issues, or can they be dismissed as mere teething troubles for a new leader adapting to challenging circumstances?

Badenoch faces a difficult landscape. The Conservatives have lost credibility and are incredibly unpopular, with Labour, the Greens, the Liberal Democrats and Reform UK all benefitting at the last election. Sir Keir Starmer has found it easy to deflect her attacks regarding key issues like the economy and immigration. We have heard some ready-made attack lines:

“Same old Tories, open borders, empty promises” and “they lost control of the economy”. 

Post-election unpopularity is expected for a defeated party, but the rise of Reform UK poses a unique challenge. A recent MRP poll by Electoral Calculus places Reform at 24% with the Conservatives at 23%. If current trends continue, the Conservatives face further punishment at the next election. Compounding this, a YouGov poll shows only 18% of Britons believe that the Conservatives have a clear sense of direction. Clearly, Ms Badenoch is struggling to communicate her platform. 

Badenoch has attempted to portray Starmer as prioritising international legal frameworks over Britain’s national interest, using his legal background against him. The tagline “he’s a lawyer, not a leader” plays into right-wing voters’ frustrations with the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). This approach allows her to address immigration while shielding herself from her party’s track record. Ms Badenoch recently reinforced this narrative in the Commons by referencing reports that Attorney General Richard Hermer is strict regarding adherence to international law in government policy. To her credit, Starmer appeared unsettled –  perhaps due to his personal friendship with Hermer. 

However, her attempt to frame Sir Keir as unprepared for PMQs, and unable to answer her questions, has been far less effective. Given his background, this was always unlikely to stick. Instead, it has made PMQs appear as if both leaders are talking past each other. Starmer answers her questions, yet Badenoch proceeds as if he hasn’t, creating the perception that she is the one not on top of her briefing and reading from a script. 

This was evident during her questioning on the Chagos Islands issue. Starmer dismissed the attack, stating it was a national security matter she would understand if she were on top of her own briefing. This reinforced the impression that the opposition leader is struggling to grasp the details of policy debates. 

The latest blunder came over a controversial court ruling allowing a Gazan family of 6 to resettle in the UK through the “Homes for Ukraine” scheme. Ms Badenoch asked the Prime Minister whether the government would appeal, and if they planned to close the loophole. Starmer stated that he disagreed with the ruling and that the government would act. Despite this, she insisted he had not answered her question, allowing the Prime Minister to quip that “her script doesn’t allow her to listen to the answer”. He also pointed out that the scheme’s legal framework was written up by the previous government. 

Badenoch’s struggles at PMQs raise doubts about her leadership. While her difficulties stem partly from the political terrain she has inherited, the onus remains on her to refine her approach. She must find ways to challenge Starmer effectively, minimise his ability to deflect attacks onto her own party, and inject a sense of purpose to her leadership. Unless she adapts quickly and finds a way to communicate her platform more effectively, discontent with her leadership will only grow.

Image: House of Commons/Wikimedia Commons