Progressive policy or pro-natal polemic?
By Madeleine Ballay
France had its lowest birth-rate since 1946 in 2023, with fewer than 700,000 births over the year. This puts the total fertility rate at 1.68
children per woman. In response to these statistics, Emmanuel Macron announced in a press conference on the 16th January that the state would begin a policy programme to engender a “demographic rearmament” – by which he means to adopt pronatalist policies – to boost France’s birth-rate.
This polemical statement has divided the French political class, raising conflicting issues of women’s rights, economic uncertainty and
fear of migration. On one hand, there has been an uproar against the military and paternalistic language of the address, as well as
the perceived injunction for women to have children. On the other, the right has broadly welcomed the announcement which it considers to be promoting ‘family values’ as well as guarding France against a demographic reliance on migration to make up labour and tax shortfalls in an ageing population.
The President announced two measures to fight infertility and dropping birth rates: an as yet undefined adaptation to parental leave which is intended to be better paid than current provisions and plans to develop reproductive healthcare for men and women. The first measure, though still vague, is intended to reduce the impact of motherhood on women’s personal finances and career prospects, by ensuring a better paid form of maternity and paternity leave. Combined with plans to increase the number of nursery places by 100,000 by 2027 (nursery care is largely free of charge in France), the President highlighted the policy’s aim to make having career while becoming a mother more accessible to women.
Emmanuel Macron announced in a press conference on the 16th January that the state would begin a policy programme to engender a “demographic rearmament”
The second set of measures, intended to improve French fertility, also appear reasonable when looked at separately from the military rhetoric with which they were initially laid out. Mr Macron announced that social security would pay for reproductive health checks from the age of twenty-five, in order to spot and prevent fertility issues promptly. He also outlined the will to strengthen measures
against endocrine disruptors – chemicals that interfere with the hormonal system – to combat rising infertility rates.
Combined with a repeated emphasis on the sanctity of the right to choose whether or not to have children, these measures appear remarkably unpolemical. So why is it that the left and women’s rights movements have taken such an issue with the presidents’
statement?
Mr Macron’s choice of language has been criticised by women’s rights organisations and feminist militants for its paternalism and association of military language to women’s reproductive autonomy. To “rearm France demographically” in order to “strengthen the nation” by “boosting birthrates” with little context explaining why people choose not to have, or to have fewer children, is a statement couched in the language of conservative pro-natalist policy, which has not historically been concerned with women’s reproductive rights.
Mr Macron’s choice of language has been criticised by women’s rights organisations and feminist militants for its paternalism and association of military language to women’s reproductive autonomy.
The association of demographic policy with the language of war and nationalism recalls the 1940s Vichy government, whose well-known motto ‘family, work, homeland’ emphasised the connection between high-birthrates, economic growth and nationalism. The
left has been quick to connect Mr Macron’s speech with similar rhetoric used by Viktor Orbán in Hungary and Vladimir Putin in Russia, where conservative ‘family values’ and a need for ‘canon-fodder’ have colluded to associate reproduction with moral and practical national security concerns.
The President has also been criticised for the marked contrast between his government’s pro- demographic-growth stance and the punitive migration bill that is being shuttled between the upper and lower houses. Hervé le Bras, the director of research at the School
for Advanced Studies in the Social Sciences (EHESS), explained that the concern about a drop in birth rates to below two children per woman is currently counterbalanced by migration to France.
Jordan Bardella welcomed the government’s announcement, commenting on national radio that both Asia and Africa have high birth rates so “if we do not support pro-natalist policies – for those who wish it – we will disappear”.
However, this kind of population growth does not interest the right. The National Rally’s president Jordan Bardella welcomed the government’s announcement, commenting on national radio that both Asia and Africa have high birth rates so “if we do not support pro-natalist policies – for those who wish it – we will disappear”. This thinly veiled endorsement of ‘Great Replacement Theory’ – a popular conspiracy which argues that immigration and low French birth rates will result in the ‘Islamo-substitution’ of the white, indigenous French – demonstrates the polarizing nature of the pronatalist policies advocated for by Mr Macron.
To ‘rearm’ a nation with a higher (indigenous) birth rate, recalls the language of Margaret Attwood’s Handmaid’s Tale as pointed out by Marine Tondelier, the leader of Europe-Ecologie-Les- Verts. However, this is also the president who last March, vowed to irreversibly enshrine the right to abortion in the Constitution. By shrouding his pro-natal policies in the language of the reactionary right, the French president has deflected attention from generally progressive policies – improved healthcare and parental leave cover – towards the identity politics that currently divide the nation.
Image: Laurie Shaull via Wikimedia Commons

