International Women’s Day: aiming for equal voices in Durham

By Madeleine Ballay

Every year, the 8th of March – International Women’s Day – brings reflections on the current state of women’s rights. We weigh the steps forwards against the sexism that continues to shape the lives of women around the world.

Here in Durham, I have spoken to three women in positions of student leadership to discuss where we are in in terms of representation in student politics, their experiences as women in visible positions of responsibility and their ideas for making Durham a more gender-equal community.

It is hard to always have to speak louder to get the attention of majority-men rooms.

Isabella Cowell Grey JCR president

The issue that was most commented on by the three interviewees was how difficult it is to have one’s voice heard equally
to men. Their concerns echo those of Kate McIntosh, the SU’s 2019-20 president. In a blog post on the SU website, she called out “Durham’s problem with respect” and the reductive language used to describe her and her work. She wrote of being told she was “bossy, manipulative, overly opinionated or ‘unsavoury’”.

Two years later, Izzy Cowell, Grey College’s outgoing JCR President, largely agrees that Durham still has a ‘problem with respect’ towards women, despite incremental progress towards equal representation. She noted the insidious comments by peers as well as University staff on her appearance rather than about her work and the sexualising Tindurs and Durfesses which undermine women’s attempts to be taken seriously in a professional capacity.

The way in which women in positions of leadership are perceived might not actively prevent them participating in a rich culture of student politics, but it is a cultural hurdle over which they must climb in order to be heard and seen equally to their male counterparts. Cowell did not expect her “skin to be thick enough”, having witnessed the treatment of SU and JCR officers before her. “It’s hard to always have to speak louder to get the attention of majority-men rooms” whilst avoiding accusations of bossiness, shrillness or of being overly emotional.

Roisin Gibbons, Durham University Labour Club’s Secretary, explained the differences she has noticed in the way in which men and women engage in student politics. “DULC is quite a male-heavy society, but a lot of the women who are involved are on the exec”. She suggests that women involved in politics find themselves having to commit themselves more entirely to their organisations in order to demonstrate expertise and be taken seriously. By placing themselves in positions of leadership and dedicating more time to a cause, women might be protecting themselves from assumptions of amateurism. Gibbons highlighted
that “it is brilliant that women are represented on the exec, but questions do need to be asked as to why women have to make politics their personality to be taken seriously.

Durham’s problem with misogyny is clearly not restricted to a ‘problem with respect’. We have a problem with sexual violence: the University was in the top ten for reported accounts of sexual violence on the Everyone’s Invited 2021 report. However, the experiences of covert, often subconscious sexism that repeatedly cropped up when talking to student leaders highlights the underlying culture which belittles the challenges faced by women in this University.

It is less how we’re treates and more how we’re seen, how far we are taken seriously.

Kathleen Peterson, durham Union society assistant custodian


We witness the evidence of this daily. Cowell referred to the regular instances of being spoken over by men. Kathleen
Peterson, Durham Union Society’s Assistant Custodian, spoke of the way in which her authority as bar supervisor of 24s is better observed when accompanied by a male colleague. Gibbons explained how certain people assume her ideas and contributions to a discussion must be those of a man. All report a certain degree of invisibility when staff or students fail to realise the extent of internalised sexism in our approach to women in this institution.

Peterson summed up the problem well: “It is less about how we’re treated, and more how we are seen, how far we are taken
seriously.” Being a woman in a visible position of leadership still requires a thickening of the skin and the resilience to regularly demand equal treatment to male counterparts.

Dismantling this culture of silent assumption surrounding gender roles would take wide ranging, coordinated action between the University, colleges and student groups, according to Cowell, Gibbons and Peterson.

Cowell argued that more research needs to be done to understand the way different genders engage in student politics. She explained that “women being more represented than men on Welfare committees and less so on Governance or Finance ones” is not a situation that should be accepted at face value. There should be a concerted effort to subvert the prevalence of traditional gender ideals at this University. Questions should be asked as to whether these gendered trends are in fact a mere reflection of society outside Durham, or whether there is a culture, a use of language that reinforces gendered thinking. Academic institutions, Peterson and Gibbons pointed out, are ideally placed to promote this social analysis, as well as to act as
settings for a larger conversation about sexism embedded in culture, language and behaviours.

Incremental steps are already taken by individual organisations on an unofficial basis. Cowell recalled a conversation with her
fellow JCR presidents (of which only three out of seventeen are women) in which they discussed the lack of women’s representation on this year’s PresCom and how they would attempt to ensure that this did not impact their work on gendered issues. Peterson spoke of the Union’s proposed women only socials, whose aim would be to dispel concerns over the institution’s historically male dominated culture. These public conversations recognising the existence of barriers to women’s participation in student politics and leadership are key to deconstructing subconscious biases surrounding representation.

Academic institutions are ideally placed to act as settings for a larger conversation about sexism embedded in culture, language and behaviours.

Roisin Gibbons, DU Labour Club Secretary


Finally, all three women emphasised the importance of University-wide leadership in the effort to combat sexism alongside colleges and student organisations. On one hand, Cowell pointed out positive steps in senior leadership – in 2022 Karen O’Brien was the first woman to become vice-chancellor – and on the other, Gibbons noted that Durham is still lagging on equal pay. In 2020-21, women occupied 38.3% of highest paid jobs, in contrast to 66.4% of the lowest paid jobs. In order to actively pursue a gender equal environment the University needs to lead in the direction it wishes to head.

Image: Matt Hrcak via Wikimedia Commons