Privacy concerns over new website Ratemash

facebook

By Jordan Harries

New website Ratemash.com is causing concern over its unauthorised use of Facebook profiles to compile lists of the “Top 50 hottest” students at UK universities.

Ratemash claims to manage students’ nightlife by providing “simple, easy, seamless” access to club events and local parties. However, the site appears to have the sole function of allowing its users to rate students based on their looks.

The site compiles two lists of the 50 most attractive males and females for 116 universities.

Anyone can access the university groups and their corresponding lists, but the site does require users to sign in using their Facebook profiles in order to participate in rating the students.

It also claims to award “modelling contracts, access to top nightclubs, spa vouchers and cash” to those in the Top 50.

The site links to Facebook automatically to source its photographs. However, many of those featured on the lists are unaware that they are featured on Ratemash at all.

It is estimated that 150,000 Facebook profiles have been used without consent.

Collingwood third year Liv Hitchings, who is ranked in the Top 50 at Durham, had no idea about Ratemash until she was notified of her appearance on the site by a friend at University College London.

She told Palatinate: “Personally, it freaks me out that they were able to take personal information without having to let me know about it.

“As flattering as it is, I don’t like that it exposes me to other people’s opinions about my appearance since it’s all without my consent.”

Calum Hughes, a John Snow third year who also appears in the rankings, argues that the information is public anyway.

“It’s our own fault for having lax Facebook privacy settings. Anyone could have found the same information, although the fact they link the Ratemash profiles straight to our Facebook accounts does make it a bit of a stalkers’ paradise.”

A Theology student at Trevs identified a difference between Facebook and Ratemash:

“People who use your Facebook profile usually know you, but Ratemash is just a random collation of profiles relying on someone’s ability to list you on a website.

“It’s just a quicker way for total strangers to look at students, and it directs them to the better-looking people at the University.”

The link for ‘Events’ brings up the message that “there are no upcoming events currently” and so Ratemash appears to be wholly geared around the ranking system.

Similarly, there is little evidence of prizes or awards given to those included in the Top 50, despite the site’s promises.

Hitchings continued: “I don’t know what the site’s function is… its claims to offer club nights are a justification for what they are doing, because rating people for the sake of it would cause uproar.”

Ratemash’s owner, Michael Healy, has said that people are invited onto the site by their friends, and are welcome to remove themselves at any time.

He has compared it to Tinder for universities, but with an extra “fun” dynamic added by the concept of the leaderboard.

However, one of Durham’s College Welfare Officers has expressed concern about the effect this may have on students’ self-esteem.

She told Palatinate that “to be outside this top 50 can also have negative consequences on individuals, especially if they are already suffering from insecurities about their looks.

“The website is entirely based on individual opinions of an image, and is irrelevant to how the person in question is ‘real life’.”

Photograph: Neeraj Kumar