Musicals: yay or nay?
By Adam Hughes and Katya Sikuade
I love musicals by Adam Hughes
I adore musicals. From the artistic grandeur of Sondheim to the toe-tapping spectacle of Lloyd Webber, for me musicals represent the epitome of theatrical entertainment.
Where else but in a musical could you find characters singing about love, death or Mormonism? For many, musicals seem to hold a collection of camp clichés interspersed with spontaneous outbursts of song.
Naturally, this is true of certain shows (Grease springs to mind) but what’s so bad about that? Embrace the camp!
What many don’t realise, however, is the huge diversity present in the world of musicals: thrillers, comedies, tragedies, and jukeboxes are but a few examples of the many genres out there.
For every theatrical genre, there is a musical. If you want to see a troupe of Mormons tap dancing, you can. If you want to see a disfigured impresario attempt to seduce an ingénue, you can.
Or if you want to kick back and share your evening with a collection of foulmouthed puppets, again you can. There is such a wide selection of shows to entertain, delight or move that I defy anyone not to find a show for them.
Yes, there are many productions that peddle the classic escapism that has become inextricably linked with the art form. I can understand why those that don’t embrace the genre find outbursts of song unusual, since ‘people don’t do that’ in real life.
Of course, people don’t burst out into song as they walk down the street, or as they saunter into Tesco, but imagine a world where they did. Imagine a world where strangers in the street join a rousing chorus as you leave your house, a world where lecturers convey their theories through a jazzy tap routine; it would be superb.
Musicals are at their best, I feel, when the dramatic action justifies the singing. Stephen Sondheim describes his use of song “as a character’s last resort,” which makes perfect sense to me; when a character is experiencing emotion so large – whether it is joy or sorrow – only song can convey the emotion.
Simple words will not be enough. This is the wonder of the genre; music is such an expressive vehicle for conveying emotion.
Whether you adore or abhor musicals, I urge you to see as many as possible. Every person should be able to find a production that will delight and amuse.
I hate musicals by Katya Sikuade
I don’t hate musicals. I have simply hated every musical I have ever seen. Don’t think I’m inexperienced, I’ve seen them all: Les Mis, Wicked, Oliver, West Side Story.
Since turning eighteen, I’ve had a glass of something cheering and alcoholic with every show I’ve seen. I have begun every musical in the highest spirits, wine in hand, eager for a laugh and a cry, my nearest and dearest around me. And every time, I’m let down.
Being, I like to think, reasonably imaginative, I have never resisted the transportation of the mind that theatre offers.
I have gone to Narnia without seasickness, I’ve been back 400 years to shudder at the horror of Macbeth, and for the first five minutes of any musical, I find myself, happily, somewhere else entirely.
But when I’m taken to the workhouse, the last thing I expect, about as inappropriate and absurd as a Star Wars ringtone in the theatre, is for timid-voiced, asthmatic little children to start singing. Singing!
One minute I’m lost in the action, convinced. Oliver is starved, stuttering; I want to run up on the stage and carry him away myself! And then all of sudden, like being slapped across the face mid-daydream, he’s got the voice of a trained soprano.
On closer inspection, he’s really rather chubby. What can I do? It simply ceases to be believable. In real life, people don’t just burst into song. At least, not the kind of people I have any inclination to spend forty pounds and three hours of my life with.
But still I find myself returning, birthday treat after disappointing birthday treat. I can’t help it; I’m an optimist. I love the theatre; it takes me somewhere else, back to the bedtime stories of my contented childhood.
I don’t know if it’s music and theatre, or musicals and me. But some things just don’t mix well. And it took writing this down for me to realise that, no matter how optimistic and hopeful I am at the start of every musical, I am never more elated than at the end.
Illustration: Charlotte Gurr

