Primark’s American Dream

By Rachel Green

Fastfashion

Back in April, Irish clothing retailer, Primark, announced plans to launch its debut US store by the end of 2015. The store, to be located in Boston, will occupy 70,000 square feet of real estate and will be the first of a series of outlets to open across the East Coast. Following on from this ambitious proposal, late last month the budget clothing chain unveiled a surprise deal with American retailer Sears to lease 7 retail spaces, including stores in New York and Philadelphia. Palatinate explores Primark’s move to the ‘land of opportunity’ in more detail to see just what the future holds for everyone’s favourite fast fashion mecca.

News of this ambitious venture has led critics to question whether the bargain retailer will be able to reach the level of economic success across the pond as it currently enjoys throughout Europe, in particular within the U.K. and Spanish markets. Writing for Fashionista, Dhani Mau has commented upon the high level of competition which the brand would face not only from fellow European imports, Topshop, Zara, and H&M, but also American value brands Forever 21 and Target. Moreover, the recent failure of value-focused British chains, such as Tesco, to succeed in the increasingly competitive American market places a question mark over whether or not there really is any hope for Primark. Faith Hope Consolo, the chairman of Douglas Elliman’s retail group, through which iconic British brands including Burberry and Jimmy Choo were brought to the US, notes, “The U.S. is a huge market by any measurement, and to get traction and a national name, generally you have to open a lot of stores. It’s not financially viable otherwise for any but the top luxury retailers, or those with a cool factor like Topshop.”

Such doubts have been countered by Primark’s business development director, Breege O’Donoghue, who stressed the efficiency of its supply chain and absence of major overheads for the company. “We’re a volume business. We sell 300 million pairs of socks a year. We sell 150 million t-shirts a year,” he has confidently remarked. Indeed, if Primark’s European statistics are anything to go by, its desire to break into the US market perhaps does not seem quite so precarious. So far this year, profits have risen by 14% on an already bumper 2013 –  the 16 weeks before the 4th of January revealed a 12% surge in sales, an achievement which finance director for Associated British Foods, Primark’s parent company, John Bason, accredits to Primark’s sharply fashion-forward mindset. “We got the stock right,” he explains. “Fun and novelty was a very big trend with Christmas jumpers, novelty T-shirts and Christmas earrings selling well.” Moreover, analysts have predicted the settlement of further deals between Primark and Sears in the future, with Darren Shirley of Shore Capital commenting that such opportunities could provide “both access to a raft of prime sites across the country and good visibility on new space development with stores opened in clusters.”

So with such a wide selection of clothing retailers to choose from, what is it that draws Europe’s fashionable set towards Primark? A haven for fast fashion at budget prices, the company’s first store was opened in Dublin by Arthur Ryan under the name of “Penneys” in 1969. Today, Primark boasts 278 stores in 9 European countries, occupying an impressive total of 10.2 million square feet of retail space. Given the enormous selection on offer (garments in the latest stock range from a black chiffon overlay dress to a casual grey sweatshirt emblazoned with a cartoon figure from Disney’s Frozen) there is arguably something to suit all tastes. Furthermore, the precarious state of the UK economy since the start of the global financial crisis in 2008 has resulted in the need for consumers to cut back on personal spending, clothing included –  here Primark’s allure needs no further explanation.

That is not to say that Primark’s success story has always been an easy ride. Despite obtaining membership of the Ethical Trading Initiative in 2006 – in which businesses, trade unions, and NGOs collaborate in dealing with labour rights issues in their respective supply chains – various reports remain replete with criticism over the company’s alleged mistreatment of its labourers. Most recently, the retailer suffered considerable damage to its reputation last year following the collapse of the Rana Plaza factory building in Dhaka, in which 1130 workers were killed and many more injured. Primark had been one of the retailers for which the factory had been supplying items.

Yet figures – such as the company’s Christmas 2013 profits, the success of which has been carried over to 2014 – have shown Primark’s ability to withstand, and indeed thrive in the face of, such difficulties. With over a year to go until the opening of the Boston store, one now begs the question: could Primark USA be a success? A retailer which has the capacity to flourish on the highly competitive UK market despite competition and controversy is surely not in with a bad chance.

Photograph: independent.co.uk