The big fur debate
By Rachel Green and Rohini Aggarwal
Earlier this month, iconic department store, Harvey Nichols, announced that it was seeking an injunction to prevent animal rights activists from protesting within 50 meters of any of its stores – a move which has once again reignited the contentious issue of fur and fashion. It’s no secret that the fur question has long been the subject of harsh critique. Indeed, alongside the size zero debate, anti-fur campaigns have come to embody the dark underbelly of the fashion realm, serving as potent ammunition for those critics of the style set. So just why does fashion continue to support the use of fur as a fashion statement? Palatinate Fashion re-evaluates the fur controversy, breaking down the main issues dominating the debate surrounding the use of this age-old sartorial mainstay.
THE ISSUE: The use of fur is nothing less than animal cruelty.
THE VERDICT?Â
Against fur: One only need look at the statistics to understand the scale of the problem: the fur industry in 2011 was worth £9 billion, a rise of over 70% in a decade, from which it can be calculated that approximately 50 million animals are killed on fur farms each year. If you look at videos from PETA’s website, which are backed by celebrities including Pink and Pamela Anderson, you will see evidence of the inhumane ways in which these creatures are slaughtered. This is not done out of necessity: the target Western markets do not suffer from unbearable winter climates, in which no garment but fur would suffice to keep its populations warm. This continued animal cruelty is therefore inexcusable.
For fur: The argument against animal cruelty would arguably tug at the heartstrings of even the most devout fur-loving fashionistas, yet it is an inaccurate reflection of certain realities. For example, surely it is hypocritical to criticise fur-wearers for the killing of animals when many are killed in an equally cruel manner for food? Indeed, the fur industry is in fact more dedicated to the humane and responsible treatment of animals than many aspects of the meat industry, with high levels of regulations across local, national and international levels. Moreover, whilst many would argue that food is necessary to sustain life and fashion isn’t, is it not also the case that one can lead just as healthy and full a life being vegetarian, or vegan? In any case, fur is an age-old, natural resource, both sustainable and biodegradable, making it a smart, eco-friendly choice of material – an oft-ignored fact that needs to be acknowledged for a fair debate.
THE ISSUE: The fashion industry should not continue to glamourize fur – it is morally irresponsible.Â
THE VERDICT?Â
Against fur: In this day and age, when we know so much about some of the brutalities of the fur industry, and have plenty of faux-fur alternatives gracing our high-street, it is both deeply disheartening and shocking that many of the most influential designers in the industry are continuing to promote the wearing of fur. Whilst it may be a sustainable and renewable source for some, for many, many others, it remains a heartless expression of vanity.
For fur: Fur has been a wardrobe staple for many consumers for many years, boasting a 100,000 year old heritage. It is durable, comfortable, and above all, practical, particularly for those in countries whose winters are harsh and dangerous. Moreover, it is the sole source of income for many whose remote regions of habitation offer little alternative in terms of securing their livelihood: even within the EU, the industry provides approximately 60,000 full-time jobs. Fur is not just about making a fashion statement: it is, for some, a lifeline.
THE ISSUE:Â Celebrities who popularise fur should be especially criticised and judged for doing so.
Against: Yes, celebrities are public figures. Yes, we are influenced by celebrity style. Yes, young girls look up to certain celebrities as role models. However, is it really fair to judge these individuals for their personal choices and single them out as the ones who are responsible for dictating choices made by the general populace? For one thing, most people simply cannot afford the fluffy designer coats worn by the likes of Kate Moss; teenagers may covet Rita Ora’s (reportedly) £30,000 mink and beaver coat, but in reality, their budgets will only stretch as far as Topshop’s £89 faux-alternative. In this light, celebrities carry very little actual influence when it comes to the sale of fur, so it perhaps unfair for anti-fur critics to hold them responsible.
For:Â Ultimately, celebrities are role models. They are aware that their style will be emulated, particularly by impressionable youngsters. Public figures will always be studied, admired, mirrored. They are reflective of the fashion industry as a whole, living representatives of current trends, and when they are seen wearing garments made of fur they are essentially projecting the message that it is acceptable to do so.
Who wins?
With winter fast-approaching, the re-ignition of the enduring debate regarding fur and the fashion industry was inevitable. For this very reason then, is it right that we should judge those who choose to wear it throughout the colder months? After all, it is their body and, with the consensual desire for freedom of expression in modern society, it is their choice of garment allowing them to express themselves creatively and individually. In a country which accepts meat-eating and a fashion industry propounding the fur-trend, shouldn’t wearing fur be acceptable for those who want to wear it, leaving those who are ethically against it free to abstain? Active promotion of animal cruelty is not a matter to be advocated, but the choices we as individuals make should not be dictated by the views of others.
Photographs courtesy of Terry Richardson (taken from oystermag.com), Steven Meisel (taken from globalfashionreport.com) and telegraph.co.uk.Â



