Price of football: what does it tell us?
By Max Daniels
Skyrocketing prices, fan protests and smug Europeans. The beautiful game has returned, along with its baggage of yet another round of ticket price rises, as revealed by the BBC’s Price of Football survey. Recording ticket prices in 207 clubs across the European Leagues, it paints a grim picture for fans, and raises questions about the future of British football.
The headline is that the average price of the cheapest tickets in English football has risen at three times the cost of living. During the 2013-14 season the cost of the cheapest match-day ticket across the top four divisions was 4.4% higher than the previous year, compared to an inflation rate of only 1.2%.
The BBC’s annual Price of Football survey produced a series of highlights. Arsenal continue to offer the most expensive match-day and season tickets, the latter costing fans £2,013, while last year’s winners Manchester City sell the cheapest annual ticket, at just £299.
Charlton Athletic provide the cheapest season ticket in England, costing only £150, yet Barcelona sell the equivalent for a more manageable £103. What is seen is that there is great variation between different clubs, leagues and countries, as there have not been uniform increases in the cost of attending a match.
However, the rises have been met with anger by many fans. The Football Supporters’ Federation claims that, “At a time when there’s more money in football than there ever has been before with the incredible television revenues coming in, it is ridiculous that fans are still being squeezed.”
The issue has even reached Westminster: Labour has promised to give fans greater power in the running of their teams, including places on the club boardroom.
So what has caused this extraordinary ballooning of ticket prices? Ultimately it is down to the need for growing revenue in the face of spiralling costs. Wages now take up on average 71% of club’s income in the Premier League, with many operating at a loss, while they are suffering rising costs in the transfer market where there is immense competition for the best players – over the summer clubs spent a record £835m on transfer fees. Financial Fair Play is a consideration for those seeking European competition, while an equivalent exists in the Football League requiring clubs to limit losses.
The group most affected will be football supporters. Significantly they face higher costs, as those who regularly attend Premier League matches pay an average of £508.55 for season tickets. That is just for the cheapest. Some will be prevented from going, and it may even lead a portion to switch allegiance – early September this year saw the fifth annual Non-League Day, when fans are encouraged to watch their local teams during the international break.
In the long-run, a more unlikely victim may be the clubs themselves. Price rises could lead to an alienation of a group integral to the game. If fewer fans in future were to attend games as a result of ticket-price hikes, this would be to the detriment of football clubs: match-day revenues in the 2012-13 season were Arsenal’s greatest source of income, representing 38% of their intake. Voicing his concern, Justin King, former chief executive of Sainsbury’s, said, “Any business that thinks it can simply rely upon the loyalty of its customers, regardless of how they treat them, in the end will fail.”
That may not be true, however. Football is remarkable as a business in that it faces extraordinary demand. Fans have not left in droves, and the trend suggests that almost certainly they will continue to fork out ever-greater amounts to attend games. The 2013-14 season saw a record 96% of seats taken – above 90% for the 17th year running. The BBC’s economics editor and Arsenal fan Robert Peston summed it up: “Only in theory do I have a choice about supporting another club or giving up on Premier League football.”
Comparisons have been made to European leagues, which seem to have much cheaper tickets than the English game. Germany’s Bundesliga offers prices as low as £10 for home games, including to titans such as Bayern Munich and Borussia Dortmund. However, statistical work has shown that German prices may actually be catching up with the English game.
What should be noted it the rises in this country may not actually be that bad. The figures should not be taken at face value, as there are variations between clubs, leagues and countries. In the Football League, the average price of a League One match-day ticket rose by almost a third, yet actually fell slightly in the Championship. To take a local example, Middlesbrough’s cheapest ticket has fallen by a whole pound since 2011.
However, the overall picture for fans remains grim. Ticket prices appear likely to continue on their upward trajectory, with economic growth seeming to return alongside the ever-growing popularity of the game. It appears that change may only be delivered if the issue becomes political. Sports Minister Helen Grant said she was ‘really concerned’ at rises, while the government is setting up an ‘expert group’ to review ticket prices, in response to Labour’s plans. Only if this story merits greater attention, however, in the run-up to next year’s election might progress be made.
It seems more likely that the problem might be addressed at the next election, closer to 2020. This will be after the next round of broadcasting-rights negotiations, which are likely to see a further growth in revenue for Premier League clubs. If these were not used to lower prices, as demanded by the Football Supporters’ Federation, then the issue may come to a political head. Until then, the advice to take when following the beautiful game is to grin and bear it.
Photograph: wikipedia
