Durham’s lights shine brighter
By Max Daniels

The Lumiere festival has, like much else coming out of Durham, headed to London. Just like we saw in November, there were a number of installations around the city for the weekend (including the flying sperm, Durham’s greatest Gif to the world, which floated above Piccadilly).
Once more organised by Artichoke, the non-profit public art group, Lumiere featured a range of large- and small-scale displays spread over three main sites (in King’s Cross, Westminster and around Leicester Square) in its first venture to the capital.
Circumnavigating King’s Cross was made possible by giant arrows and associated high visibility-wearing stewards, cheerful despite a winter wind not justified this far south. The crowds were low, surprising given the warnings and notifications sent in stern emails by London Underground, and it seemed more like the event had caught people off-guard, as if, upon exiting the train station, they had stumbled across the city’s most exciting January event. The area felt like a giant urban playground, at the centre of which stood the brilliant Circus of Light by Ocubo: light installations were engaged in a game of hide-and-seek, waiting for viewers to catch them before playfully revealing themselves.

So how does it compare to Durham? It’s essentially the same: pretty light installations displayed strategically in the city as part of a loop, with gawping tourists in tow. Except this was London. Everything was much more spread out, requiring public transport, or very slow walking. On the first night it was not busy; but come Saturday evening a few installations had to be turned off temporarily and King’s Cross station evacuated following overcrowding. Durham was packed – hence the restricted entry to the Bailey that prevented us visiting Tesco in those crucial hours approaching 7pm – but nothing like this.
Artichoke made use of Durham’s greatest assets in the form of the cathedral and castle, and these far outshone anything on offer in the capital. The light installations worked beautifully against these enormous historical buildings, a new mystery was waiting around every corner. The closest London came was the lighting up of the façade of Westminster Abbey, with the disciples drowned in exuberant technicolour to bring them alive. Overall, while visually stunning, the organisers made better use of Durham’s larger buildings.
For the smaller-scale installations, the two festivals were broadly similar in their output. London had some imaginative offerings, such as a range of glowing dresses floating eerily in the dark in King’s Cross and Liberty’s. In one piece, entitled Sanctuary to represent protection against the harsh winter, small birdhouses sat within the trees in a park in Mayfair, where they emitted noise so that viewers were surrounded by birdsong.

Given its size, it seems that Lumiere simply works better in Durham. Wandering around town, for both the small and large features, it really felt as if you were seeing it ‘in a new light’. London’s event, while pretty and an excuse to explore hitherto-unknown parts of the city (at least for me), felt insignificant against its backdrop.
Durham’s superiority may not last. Artichoke have stated their wish to put the festival on again in London. Were this to become a regular event, with the full force of the mayor and the phenomenal advertising machine that is the Tube, it could be upgraded and extended beyond its current scale. There will be numerous opportunities to showcase some of the capital’s landmarks, as well as its innumerable nooks and crannies, which would be hard for hard for any other city to rival. However, for now, we can say that Durham still enjoys Britain’s best light show.
