Power and gender are not interlinked

Queen Titanic Belfast

by Katie Shuff

The question of gender equality within the widely regarded male dominated world of work is still a pertinent issue today. Undoubtedly, the eagerly anticipated list of the most powerful women in Britain put together by Radio Four’s Women’s Hour goes some way to counteract this sexism and to celebrate the achievements of women over a wide range of professions. But who came out on top?

It may come as a surprise, but the panel of judges, with the help of Women’s Hour listeners, voted the Queen as the most powerful women in Britain.

The panel justified their decision by emphasising the potential power the Queen holds, dubbing this ‘soft power’. For Dame Jenni Murray, a co-presenter on Women’s Hour, “power is everything the Queen stands for.” But surely every woman has the potential to be powerful?

The list is a mixed one, with more obvious choices such as Theresa May, Home Secretary, who came in at number two. Ana Botín, CEO of Santander UK (the first woman to run a major bank in the UK) and the Baroness Hale of Richmond, the first woman to sit in the British Supreme Court, placed third and fourth respectively.

Then there are some anomalies. I have no doubt that Adele is an inspiration to many, but is she the twentieth most powerful woman in Britain? Similarly, do the likes of Dawn French (41st) and Clare Balding (36th) actually yield any form of power other than entertaining an audience?

By no means do I want to belittle their achievements, nor the fact that these women have reached the top of their fields, but the power of some women on the list seems a little trivial, weakening its overall impact.

Whilst reading the list I was struck by the deeper issues surrounding gender equality within the workplace. Most importantly, by publishing a list comprised solely of women are we thereby suggesting that women’s success should be kept separate from that of their male counterparts?

Women exercising power should not be a surprise and more needs to be done to remove this detrimental stereotype.

By seeing the achievements of these women as an exception, are we admitting that we expect less of ourselves? And by publishing it, are the judges and listeners of Women’s Hour unwittingly reinforcing gender stereotypes by making an example of women in places of high power?

Clearly there is a fine line.  Alice Feinstein, editor on Women’s Hour, claims that the programme wanted to “start a conversation about women and their power in the UK, analysing how women are making their mark and identifying the areas where their voices are not being heard.”

However, in her upcoming book, ‘Lean in: Women Work and the Will to Lead’, Sheryl Sandberg argues that women are “quietly checking out of their careers, years before they actually start a family.”

Futhermore, Emma Rowley wrote in The Telegraph that the perpetuation of inequality in the workplace was not due to a glass cieling, but rather to a ‘cliff’ – not at the top, but in the middle – which women consequently fall off when they decide they want to start a family.

This ‘cliff’ is highlighted in research which shows that even when men and women enter a company in equal proportions, the number of women drops the higher up the chain you go.

Furthermore, despite Vince Cable boasting that only seven firms in the prestigious FTSE 100 index have all male boards, just two of these one hundred corporations are led by women.

Clearly women cannot be held solely accountable for this clear office sexism, but the female belief that we have to start planning for a family before we are even in a relationship is enabling men to maintain these stereotypes against working women, allowing such attitudes to thrive.

Ultimately, we should not need separate power lists for men and women. It should not be shocking or an exception to see a woman running a corporation or acting as CEO of a major banking organisation, and the fact that only six women featured in Forbes’ Most Powerful People’s List is extremely worrying.

Women exercising power should not be a surprise and more needs to be done to remove this detrimental stereotype.

However, whilst compiling lists does to some extent draw attention to the power held by some women it does little to motivate others and unwittingly reinforces the stereotypes and uneasy feelings about women in power by marking them out as different.