Portico Prize Shortlist: ‘The Boy with the Perpetual Nervousness’

By Shauna Lewis

A memoir of his experiences in adolescence, Graham Caveney’s The Boy with the Perpetual Nervousness is a harrowing read about the sexual abuse of his younger self at the hands of his priest and mentor. Moving between the political and the personal (whilst acknowledging everything in between) Caveney’s narrative is dryly funny, whilst being made of difficult matter.

Undoubtedly it’s not an easy read. Graphic descriptions of his abuse are littered throughout the book, as his narrative hovers like a film camera above his younger self, documenting each and every encounter. It’s uncomfortable and it makes your skin crawl as Caveney talks about the grooming he resented as a child, whilst also yearning for the cultural knowledge his abuser provided.

his narrative hovers like a film camera above his younger self, documenting each and every encounter

Cavaney’s voice is comical, bursts of sarcasm which later develop into a cynicism for life as the priests’ actions continue to affect his later time at university and his adult career. It’s a slow descent, beginning with off-hand comments and wandering thoughts about trivial things to distract himself from his experiences. Later, the sarcasm becomes an outlook, a scepticism of life and the faith he once held: “The Catholic Church had been my one totalising system of belief, and I was damned if I was going to throw myself into another.”

Every time I almost expect the narrative to move away from the ramifications of these events, onto an easier life at university – the narrative flips back and shows me this isn’t something Caveney can escape from. It infiltrates his life in nearly every aspect, rids me of the romantic coming-of-age narrative I want the novel to have, where his younger self triumphs. That narrative can’t exist, and the brutally funny yet uncomfortably explicit prose demonstrates that.

Amongst this narrative though, exists the story of a young boy trying to find his footing in the two worlds he occupies. From a Northern working-class background to the middle-class population of Warwick University, he feels part of neither. His narrative is conflicted and confused about what he thinks of his working-class family, and I’m not sure whether I’m meant to approve or disapprove of those feelings, but they exist in the most honest part of Caveney’s narrative. It feels like an unfiltered insight into his mind, so often we see personal essays built to appease the liberal mind, but he lets his narrative flow with the ugly thoughts he’s not meant to have, as well as his more progressive line of thinking.

A packed story, sometimes his prose is so dense with information that I have to go back and read it again. It’s something I get used to, even appreciate, as Caveney’s claustrophobic narrative encloses you within his experience. His extensive cultural references allow me to live his adolescence with him – whilst making me feel like I should listen to more music – but sometimes he gets lost in the details.

Caveney takes the past decade’s obsession with the personal essay and elevates it to be something unfiltered and more complicated than most

As the memoir draws to a close, and brings us to Caveney’s present life, it feels rather underwhelming. So much has been said, it’s hard to wrap it up. References to alcohol addiction and drug dependency are left at the edges of the novel, we get a hint of what has happened but never the full story. Too dark to disclose almost, it leaves the memoir feeling unfinished, but Caveney has to keep some of the story; we’re only entitled to so much.

A difficult read, but a necessary one, Caveney takes the past decade’s obsession with the personal essay and elevates it to be something unfiltered and more complicated than most – making it hard to stop thinking about.

The Portico Prize awards ÂŁ10,000 to the book that best evokes the spirit of the North of England. Palatinate is reviewing the shortlist and a winner will be announced on 23rd January 2020.

Image: The Portico Prize for Literature in association with The Portico Library, Manchester