Where teaching literature goes wrong
By Shauna Lewis
Being an English Literature student, I think I have a natural bias to the question of whether studying literature takes all the joy out of it. At this point, if I haven’t at least enjoyed discussing a book then I’ve made a very bad choice with my degree.
We should be taught literature; I believe the real issue lies in how we are forced to engage with its content. Durham’s English department itself has maintained the traditional route of three-hour examinations, and it is in this system I think that the idea of enjoying literature is frequently lost.
the real issue lies in how we are forced to engage with its content
Cambridge academic Priyamvada Gopal recently commented on Twitter: “The more I read undergrad dissertations- even the weaker ones teach me something- the more I am convinced this three-hour exam routine must stop.’ She added that it ‘rewards’ more ‘quick performance which then goes on to afflict journalism, law etc. Real thinking is the key.’
At an earlier stage, like A-Level or GCSE, I was allowed to sit with a set number of texts for a year. This allowed for far more ‘real thinking’ about the narrative and structure, but most importantly benefitted my own interpretation and enjoyment.
Yes, Of Mice and Men has become something of a Twitter joke from the GCSE syllabus and a revolutionary novel like Jane Eyre has been dissected many a time to uncover that it’s not really the feminist tale it professes to be, but we’re still discussing them. Whether we realise it or not, the novels and plays we’re forced to engage with for a year, make much more of an impact than those to which we make a fleeting visit.
long-form essays have impacted me in the way learning about literature should
I’m not suggesting that the English department limits its modules to studying three texts a year. A degree has to cover significantly more ground than a GCSE or A-Level syllabus. Naturally though, when you spend more time with a text, you develop a better understanding of it, and isn’t that the point of learning? Not to push through two 500-page novels in an hour-long lecture and feel as if you barely scratched the surface.
For me, essays have resulted in a greater knowledge and love of a text than exams ever have done. I’ve had time to choose a question I like, and I’ve had time to think about the text itself, much like I did at A-Level. In comparison to a hastily formed plan and answer in an exam, essays seem like a godsend.
My seminar module this year on Toni Morrison let me pick a question which I was really interested in, focusing on her position as a black female author in a white-male-dominated space. This extra time I was allowed for reading changed my perception of her. Since then, I’ve found myself considering the insights I gained out of that essay and have thought about it in relation to other authors I’ve come across.
the value of literature doesn’t emerge from a year condensed into one sitting
In essence, long-form essays have impacted me in the way learning about literature should. They’ve helped me in terms of the specific work I’ve studied and they’ve enlightened me in relation to all literature. Whereas if you ask me what I wrote about Much Ado About Nothing and As You Like It in my Shakespeare exam, I can’t even remember the question.
In my view, Durham’s English department is distressingly out of date and its assessment methods are only a minor part of the ways it needs to catch up. Other English departments, such as the one at Newcastle University, assess English Literature degrees largely on coursework. Other universities have learned that the value of literature doesn’t emerge from a year condensed into one sitting, so I don’t see why one of the leading English departments in the country can’t either.
Photograph: Emmanuel Phaeton via Unsplash
