Pope Francis fails to deliver the promised land of LGBT+ inclusion
By Jonathan Murden
Pope Francis has a reputation for being the ‘cool’ Pope. Ever since his election, he has been lauded in the mainstream media as the beginning of a progressive revolution in the Catholic Church. It is surprising then that Francis so often fails to meet these expectations.
Whilst in Poland a few weeks ago, the Pope held a private meeting with local bishops in which he condemned what he referred to as the “ideological colonization” of “gender ideologies”. According to the Pontiff, in some developing nations, funds for education are only allocated on the condition that children will be taught “that everyone can choose their gender.” Francis referred to this as the “annihilation of man in the image of God.”
His image of the ‘annihilation’ of human life to describe trans people was, to say the very least, ill-timed. Earlier that same week, Dee Whigham, a twenty five year old black transwoman, was stabbed to death in a Mississippi hotel room. According to HRC, at least fourteen trans people have been killed in 2016 so far in the US alone.
Some commentators have seen Francis’ remarks in Poland as hypocritical, with the Huffington Post running a piece entitled ‘The Pope of Two Minds Disillusions Us’. How can he preach a message of love and openness one day and condemn LGBT+ people the next? Whatever happened to ‘who am I to judge?’ But this perception of hypocrisy is largely the result of a misunderstanding of Francis’ project.
The media, thirsty for celebrities, labelled Francis as a ‘liberal’ almost immediately, largely due to what were perceived to be criticisms of his ‘conservative’ predecessor, Pope Benedict XVI, his refusal to live in the Apostolic Palace, his rejection of certain regal vestments, and his strident critiques of global capitalism. Francis has also emphasised the importance of dialogue within the Church on issues of gender and sexuality, and he has held personal meetings and private audiences with LGBT+ people during his time as Pope.
In his address to the conclave in 2013, which convened to appoint a new pope following Benedict’s resignation, Francis, then Cardinal Bergoglio, contrasted a ‘theological narcissism’, in which the Church exists only for its own sake, with “a desire in the Church to come out of herself” for the sake of the Gospel and the marginalised. This was interpreted as a critique of the centralised bureaucracy that so dominates contemporary Catholicism. Such an interpretation was confirmed by his later criticisms of the Roman Curia and his move towards giving greater deference to the Synod of Bishops, rather than making decisions alone.
Francis was certainly appointed as a reformer, but it is not necessarily the kind of reform critics of the Church, especially from a secular perspective, would like to see most.
There are grassroots movements within the Catholic Church looking towards greater LGBT+ inclusion, including, for some, a revision of the Church’s historic teaching on gender and sexuality. However, these movements are largely unrelated to Francis, and have even faced increased opposition since his ascension to the Holy See. The Pope aims to decentralise the authority of the ordained hierarchy and to rectify its past wrongdoings, so that the Church might better act as a conduit of God’s mercy to the world, especially to those at the margins of society, but all from within a historically Catholic identity. For example, his critique of capitalism emerges from the tradition of Catholic social teaching, which condemns any system oriented around profit or growth rather than from a need to promote the common good in and of itself.
Similarly, his strong emphasis on mercy, prominent in almost all of his published writings, has its roots in the teachings of figures such as his namesake, St Francis of Assisi, and ultimately, in God’s mercy to the world in the life of Jesus. On Francis’ reading, these traditions in Catholic history do not necessitate changes in Church teaching, and even prohibits such developments. And whilst some dissent from this official interpretation of the Roman Catholic tradition, we should not be surprised that the Pope does not.
Whilst Francis has sought to cultivate a more welcoming and inclusive posture towards LGBT+ people, this is a posture from within the boundaries of traditional Catholic dogma. After the papacy of Benedict XVI, this is indeed a radically new posture – although Benedict and Francis have a lot more in common than is usually acknowledged, it would be difficult to argue that Benedict had any interest in reaching out to the LGBT+ community. However, most LGBT+ advocates would say that a change in tone is not enough, as they see the exclusion of LGBT+ people as an intrinsic result of the official teaching. And though there are people within Catholicism who are working towards a more radical vision of LGBT+ inclusion, Pope Francis is definitely not among them.
Photograph: Catholic Church England and Wales via Flickr and Creative Commons
