Labour’s Identity Crisis

By Jonathan Murden

After what seems like an eternity of bickering, backbiting, and ‘scandal’ (Traingate anyone?), Jeremy Corbyn has been re-elected as leader of the Labour Party.

We’re all familiar with the debate; the coup says that Labour must be in power to implement its policies, and that it needs a potential Prime Minister, not merely a protester or a Leader of the Opposition; the pro-Corbyn camp responds that Labour must represent a real alternative to the Tories, and under Corbyn Labour is a mass political movement. We’re also all familiar with the accusations that have been thrown across the divide; ‘Blairite’, ‘Trot’, ‘Tory’, ‘Loony Left’.

One thing that unites both sides is their fixation on Jeremy Corbyn himself. His opponents often speak as if all that is required is that Corbyn be removed; his defenders often talk as if all that is required is that he stay. However, the crisis that the Labour Party is currently undergoing has much deeper roots than Corbyn’s leadership. The apocalyptic tone of many discussions of this election may be comforting in some sense – as long as the problem is merely centred on one man, whether saviour or antichrist, the solution is plain and simple. However, this is a distraction from the more serious issues underlying this contest.

We could identify the crisis as beginning in 1994. Before this, Labour had been the party of socialism in quite a literal sense; it aimed to secure the means of production of the workers. Under Blair, though he still identified Labour as a ‘democratic socialist’ party, with social justice as a central principle, it radically changed its approach, arguing that the forces of the free market could bring about an economy that worked for everybody – equality of opportunity, if not equality of outcome.

It would be a cliché to call Blair a Tory, but he did adopt Tory strategy. Labour’s rebranding was aimed at the upper and middle classes, the idea being that those who are prospering can be kept in this position with the support of those rising in economic status. And this was very successful; Blair won three terms with it. However, it should be recognised that these victories only occurred in a very particular context. The Conservative Party’s reputation for economic stability had been effectively destroyed by the Black Wednesday crisis of 1992, and they were wracked with internal division over the European Union. New Labour stepped in to fill the gap left by the failure of the Tories.

We could say that this was where Labour’s contradictions were first established; when the traditionally socialist roots of the party were papered over to create a new neoliberal front, leaving the classic Labour base behind. However, this would be too simplistic. Whilst it is true that Blair cemented the crisis into party policy, Labour’s troubles go further back than this.

The Labour Party was originally the parliamentary representative of the labour movement – of the trade unions. It arose organically from the action of union activists around the country, and was centralised as the ‘Labour Representation Committee’ in 1900. The rise of the party as an alternative to the Tories can largely be attributed to this strong base in the working class via the unions. However, from the 80s onwards, these conditions no longer exist. Thatcher’s war on the unions destroyed their relevancy as a political movement, and it also painted them as enemies to national security and stability.

Labour’s core identity resided in the unions, and then the unions were gone. As such, New Labour did not leave the traditional Labour base behind. They had already been left behind by political and economic factors almost entirely outside of Labour’s control, and New Labour was simply an attempt to create a political platform in the aftermath of this.

The decline of the unions left Labour as a merely parliamentary movement, and one of the continuities in Labour politics from the 90s all the way up to Ed Miliband is a focus on how best to manage social processes, including, among others, Parliament and the economy, rather than changing them. Uniting New Labour and what is known as the soft left, perhaps best exemplified by Ed Miliband, is this managerial attitude to politics, resting on the premise that more radical change would be impossible.

In many ways, Corbyn is a refreshing change to this state of affairs, but he himself is by no means a resolution to the crisis. There are no messiahs in politics. The Labour Party does not yet know its identity in a world without the unions, the world of globalised neoliberalism, and until it does, it will remain inefficient in its pursuit of change for the good.

Garry Knight via Flickr