Point and shoot: how bodycams distort crime narrative
By Tom Rainbow
Sunday morning brought the news that twenty-eight year old Atatiana Jefferson, an African-American woman from Fort Worth, Texas, had been shot and killed in her home by police officers.
Whilst the details of the incident are yet to be fully released, shootings of unarmed African-Americans follow an all-too-similar story. In this case, a neighbour called the emergency services to report Jefferson’s front door being left open. When the police arrived, Jefferson went to her bedroom window to investigate. Within seconds, and without the officers even having identified themselves, Jefferson was shot and died at the scene.
The body cam footage showing the events leading up to the shooting has now been released, if only in a heavily edited form. In particular, a still lifted from the footage has been reproduced by numerous media outlets. It has mostly been blurred out, with only the faint image of a gun on Jefferson’s floor left visible.
In April of this year I wrote about the fire at the Notre-Dame cathedral in Paris. For many days afterwards, it seemed my Facebook and Instagram feed was swamped by images of this world-renowned building’s sorry state. What does it mean, then, when the only image associated with Atatiana Jefferson’s shooting is of a gun in her home? What are the implications of seeing these tragic events only from the perspective of the police officer? I worry that, in a perverse way, the image of the gun on the floor is asking us to justify the police officer’s actions.
What does it mean, then, when the only image associated with Atatiana Jefferson’s shooting is of a gun in her home?
Of course, the shooting of Atatiana Jefferson is unjustifiable in the same way the shootings of Michael Brown, Walter Scott and countless others were utterly inexcusable. But with every new shooting comes another piece of body cam footage, asking us to retrace the officer’s footsteps and see through the officer’s eyes.
In these cases, then, the very nature of photography seems fundamentally pernicious. The influential essayist Susan Sontag described a similar phenomenon in her essay ‘In Plato’s Cave’. Sontag was affected by the war photography emerging out of Vietnam at the time, but her comments still resonate with this latest trend of violence.
In day-to-day instances, photography is a passive yet harmless act by the photographer. In war photography or body cam footage, however, the very act of photography is a matter of life and death. “The act of photographing is more than passive observing”, Sontag writes. Instead, the photograph records the photographer’s decision not to help the victim of violence.
The very terminology of photography – the ‘snapshot’ or the ‘point-and-shoot’ camera – suggests its victimisation of the subject. “Just as the camera is the sublimation of the gun”, Sontag notes, “to photograph someone is a sublimated murder.”
The very terminology of photography – the ‘snapshot’ or the ‘point-and-shoot’ camera – suggests its victimisation of the subject.
When seeing the body cam footage from Jefferson’s shooting, it is all too easy to feel only a passing sense of horror. The news media’s presentation of such images can make events feel like a “soft murder”, appropriated so as to cause only a certain level of discomfort. Noting the US media’s indifference to the horror of the Vietnam War, Sontag argues that “to take a picture is to have an interest in things as they are, in the status quo remaining unchanged.” In short, a camera invites indifference.
It is difficult in these circumstances to know what could help prevent body cam footage appearing in newsfeeds again. To see these images as a white male can induce a feeling somewhere between guilt and powerlessness. But remembering Sontag’s words, we can at least make a conscious effort to challenge photographs and the narratives they suggest.
We must challenge the image of the gun on the ground; we must challenge the silhouette in the window. For, of course, the only image we can’t see is that of an innocent twenty-eight year old, playing video games with her nephew on a Friday night.
Image by Ryan Johnson/North Charleston via Flickr
