Adjusting to life in an automated world
By Abraham Leonard Keefe
A few years ago, the Institute for Public Policy Research made a startling prediction: that roughly half of the current jobs in the North East were at risk of being replaced, the highest amount for any region in the UK. Not by a wave of refuge-seeking immigrants, nor by a mass post-Brexit outsourcing to China or India, but by a looming new industrial revolution, bringing with it the prospect of large-scale automation.
This topic has not gone completely unnoticed – across the pond, the scare of a great technological replacement has been discussed by a wide variety of political personalities, from Tucker Carlson to Andrew Yang. Both have agreed that the US economy needs to be directed towards the people and their right to work, above the economic growth possible with technology, and they aren’t alone.
Efforts to reign in big tech have been taken by the right and left alike, the deceleration of automation being a primary demand. However, it’s largely a populist talking point, as populism generally relies on the demonisation of a specific group, be it justifiably (such as in relation to certain corporate bodies), strategically (such as scapegoating immigrants, Jews, or freemasons), or just absurdly (such as blaming lizardmen, annunaki, or aliens). With automation, there are elements of all three.
Of course, there are also those that herald the coming of full automation joyously, such as those at the head of some businesses and corporations. And why wouldn’t they? With the amount of exploitation in present-day labour relations and the focus on systematic and standardised mass production, the robot is the cheap, obedient perfectionist needed to produce and distribute a product, where human error and conflicted interest no longer factor into the profit-making equation. It’s undeniable that with automation, production efficiency is vastly increased.
The robot is the cheap, obedient perfectionist needed to produce and distribute product
So then in terms of adequately producing goods for humanity, surely efficiently automated production would be collectively beneficial? Sadly, no – efficient production does not always correlate to collectively efficient distribution across the populace. In fact, technological acceleration could end up as hugely damaging to collective human functionality, in that the distribution of the produced goods could become massively unequal.
Without human labour being a necessity, suddenly mass amounts of the population become useless to the rich and powerful. Without the leverage of being a necessity for the wealth accumulation of the wealthy, suddenly the workers are deprived of the ability to use many of their most successful tactics, including unionisation, strike action and democratically elected government.
Private control of produced goods becomes incontestably unlimited
Private control of produced goods becomes incontestably unlimited, and assuming we still wish to enjoy those goods (including basic necessities), we would continuously have to fully appease their will. Any tiny existing chance of social mobility would be completely wiped out, and those who have made a fortune through exploitation and corrupt lobbying would be cemented ever more to their post at the top of society.
In essence, technological acceleration is fundamentally an acceleration of corporate capitalism and the power of the capitalist class. It’s a facet of the neoreactionary movement of Curtis Yarvin and Nick Land, who have heavily promoted a “Dark Enlightenment” of a corporate fascist society concerned only by profit and efficiency. Neoliberal and neoconservative politics have been steadily paving the way for neoreactionism with their own appeasement of multinational corporations, with the privatisation of everything from industry to the justice system, and now with the unprecedented access of Amazon and Google’s CEOs to the Pentagon.
Yet at the same time, holding back automation and technology could also cause concern for an ever-growing population, in which people are systematically overworked and often treated as commodities by states and corporations. We need that efficiency in production, yet we have to be careful to avoid detrimental practices such as overproduction, overconsumption, impoverishment and unfair distribution. And in order to secure that, the workers and consumers of the world would need equal, collective, and democratic control over the means of production and distribution.
Furthermore, automation also poses a metaphysical question to humanity, as to our role in an automated world. Manual, material labour would no longer be a human task, and hence perhaps human purpose would manifest itself from an increasingly intellectual angle, championing human subjectivity and abstract thought over immersion in the material world. Within a world of automation, democracy, equal opportunity and collective property, perhaps we could more easily have all our material needs catered for, to enable a perpetual immersion in our new task as human beings, securing “intellectual perpetuity” regarding the efficient generation and accumulation of abstract thought.
Automation also poses a metaphysical question to humanity
Establishing Directly Democratic Egalitarian Collectivism would naturally contain many obstacles: we may even need revolutionary action to topple corporate power, we may have to act fast while we still have the power and leverage to enact change, and we may need to address the psychological effects of unjustified hierarchy in a way no movement has ever done before. Not to mention that Directly Democratic Egalitarian Collectivism is hardly a very catchy name – if only Marx and Engels had a more succinct term we could use…
Image by Jeena Paradies via Flickr
