Play equipment removal provokes student anger

by Tim Perry

The removal of play equipment from a Durham play park has been condemned by Durham students as well as residents.

Durham County Council judged the play equipment in the Allergate Play area as unsafe and has since removed the slide, see-saw, roundabout and swings and ‘rocking-bike’. This has provoked student discontent as well as widespread anger from the community.

Kitty Duffill-Telsnig, a Trevelyan student who lives in The Avenue, labelled the move as “ridiculous”: “I can understand them removing it if they would replace it with new ‘safety approved’ equipment. But it is more detrimental to children if they haven’t got anything to play on or with”.

One second year student who lives in New Street, near the play area, also expressed dismay at the Council’s action: “Unless there’s direct evidence that the equipment’s unsafe I can’t see how it poses a threat. It’s up to the parents to make sure their kids play safely”.

“The world is a dangerous place and children should learn for themselves to stay out of danger”.

Upon hearing the news, a second year physics student labelled it as “awful”, saying “the children need somewhere to go”.

Another student living in the area said: “It seems an extreme measure to take and just encourages kids to play on games consoles or on the computer”.

“This is detrimental to both their physical health (as they’ll be getting less exercise) and their mental development – they have less contact with other children so their social skills will be underdeveloped”.

Local Residents have also been highly critical of the Council’s removal of the apparatus.

Ruth Chambers, who lives nearby, told the Durham Times: “The playground’s been used for ten to fifteen years. It seems crazy that they have suddenly decided it is not suitable”.

Sarah Loach, who lives near Allergate in Brass Thill, said: “People are always talking about kids getting more exercise and then the council takes the play equipment away”.

Christine Stainthorpe, who runs the nearby Stepping Stones Nursery whose children often used the play area, told The Northern Echo: “The equipment was old but there was nothing broken, there was nothing that would make you say. ‘I wouldn’t put my children in there’. It was all perfectly usable”.

Meanwhile Durham  County Councillor for Neville’s Cross, Nigel Martin, said he was “hopping mad”: “All I can promise is that we will be doing our utmost to get new play equipment installed as soon as possible”.

But Durham County Council’s head of sport and leisure, Steve Howell, defended the move on the grounds of health and safety.

He said: “All the council’s play areas are regularly inspected to ensure they do not pose a risk to the children.

“On rare occasions equipment has to be removed. In this case, the inspection showed significant corrosion on all equipment which could not be safely repaired.

“This is the first play area where equipment has been removed without prior notice and with no immediate plans to replace it. The park will remain green space for play and a decision will be made regarding equipment in the future.

He added that the council remained committed to providing “high quality play experiences” to Durham residents and that over one million pounds had been invested in the plan this year.

Nigel Dodds, the council’s sport and leisure manager, said the equipment was removed because it was unsuitable for upgrading, adding that most of it was manufactured before 1998, when European safety standards replaced British measures.

But David Yearley, from the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents, was quoted in the press as saying: “Generally speaking, it is important to recognise that compliance with the standards is not mandatory”.