High Court rejects students’ tuition fees claim

Two school students have lost their High Court case arguing that the rise in tuition fees is illegal.
Callum Hurley and Katy Moore took the government to court last November claiming the rise in tuition fees up to £9,000 per year, as universities such as Durham will charge, breached human rights, discriminating against poor students and those from ethnic minorities.
However judges at the High Court in London rejected their case, saying that it would “not be appropriate” to repeal the government’s Higher Education Regulations because of “very substantial compliance” of those recognising the validity of higher fees.
There was however admission that the government had failed “fully to carry out” its public sector equality duties. These duties dictate that consideration must be given to the chances of a disproportionate and discriminatory impact on ‘protected’ groups in society.
Lord Justice Elias said: “There can be no doubt that a steep increase in fees alone would discourage many from going to university and would in particular be likely to have a disproportionate impact on the poorer sections of the community.
“However, the availability of loans mitigates that effect. Given the existence of the various measures which are directed specifically at increasing university access to poorer students, I do not think that at this stage it is sufficiently clear that they will be disadvantaged under the new scheme”.
She added that reversing the fee increase would cause “administrative chaos” and “significant economic implications”.
The students had argued that the government was acting in breach of a protocol in the European Union’s convention on human rights, which states that everyone has a right not to be discriminated against in the provision of education. They also feared the widening of the gap between rich and poor students, and how the fee hike might affect less well off, black and disabled students.
In a statement, Katy Moore, a student from London, said: “I am very pleased with the outcome. For the court to recognise that the government’s actions were unlawful is a great achievement”.
Reacting to the news, Tessa Gregory, of the law firm which represented the teenagers, was happy that the government had been shown to have acted wrongly. She said: “The court made a clear declaration that the government failed to comply with its public sector equality duties.
“It found the government’s analysis on equality issues was inadequate. Whilst our clients are disappointed that the court chose not to quash the regulations, they are pleased with the recognition that the government failed in its duties to properly think through the equality implications of its decision”.
But a spokesperson for the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills said: “The court recognised the consultation and analysis we carried out”.
“They also recognised the extensive debate which took place on how those from disadvantaged backgrounds can be encouraged to enter higher education”.
“We are pleased the court rejected outright the suggestion that our student finance reforms breach students’ human rights”.
