Plagiarism Exposed
AS THE EPIPHANY term is dominated by looming essay deadlines, an increasing number of students may be concerned about issues of plagiarism.
After interviewing a selection of students, Palatinate has discovered that many are unaware of what constitutes plagiarism and are worried about accidentally cheating.
So what exactly is plagiarism and what happens if you get caught?
University guidelines define plagiarism as “unacknowledged quotation or close paraphrasing of other people’s writing, amounting to the presentation of another person’s thoughts or writings as one’s own. This includes material which is available on the worldwide web and in any other electronic form.”
Most people are aware that directly copying work and failing to reference sources is plagiarism.
However, the university’s official guidelines also include more subtle ways in which plagiarism may be committed, many of which students may be unaware of.
Copying song melodies, pictures or photographs, computer codes, spreadsheets and work conducted in a group without acknowledgement, counts as plagiarism.
‘Patch Writing’, a method of collecting work from various sources together with words of your own, is also forbidden. Students are even at risk of plagiarising their own work by submitting almost identical work without referencing.
Finally, websites that offer essay writing services for a fee sometimes give a ‘no plagiarism promise’.
However, submitting ‘bought’ essays still constitutes plagiarism. In addition to this, the university also considers uploading work to websites where it can be sold as plagiarism, and administers similar punishment.
In addition to the vigilance of markers, Durham University uses powerful computer programs to detect plagiarised work, such as ‘Turnitin’.
Some students may think that modern technology has made cheating easier. HOwever, the internet and technology have in fact made it easier to detect plagiarism. The program compares assignments with thousands of books, over 10,000 newspapers, magazines and journals, over 70 million student papers and over 10 billion web pages, highlighting similarities when they occur.
Sam Dale, Durham University’s Academic Registrar, told Palatinate that the program is constantly being developed as its archive is expanded each time an essay is run through it.
Mr Dale also stressed that plagiarism is taken very seriously by all departments within the university.
Durham University’s policy regarding plagiarism penalties differs for formative and summative assignments.
When plagiarised work is submitted for formative assessment, the student is made aware of the seriousness of his or her action and the problem “should be dealt with informally by the department.” Summative plagiarism is treated far more seriously.
A report is first made to the Chair of the subject in question or the Joint Board of Examiners. If there is sufficient evidence, a sub-group panel of the Board of Examiners is created.
The student is summoned to meet with the board and the reporting examiner, where evidence is presented and the student is asked to account for it.
The panel considers the evidenc; if the case is deemed serious, the Chair makes a formal accusation of dishonesty to the Senate Disciplinary Committee, citing a Major Offence.
If the case progresses to the Senate Discipline Committee, the student receives a written summons to attend a hearing, and the Principal of the student’s college and the Head of the Department will be invited to attend the meeting.
During the hearing, the student is given a chance to speak, and the Principal of the student’s college and the Departmental Head submit statements regarding the student’s general conduct at university.
After a final statement from the student, a decision is reached by the committee and punishment decided upon if guilty.
Each case of plagiarism is treated differently, as varying degrees of mitigating circumstances tend to apply.
In the most serious cases, expulsion can occur. Other punishments include a formal reprimand, zero marks awarded for a module, or a reduction in the degree classification to be awarded.
Many students seem to think that this university policy is designed to scare them into avoiding plagiarism, and that the punishments are rarely meted out.
However, between October 2007 and December 2008 three students were expelled from Durham University for submitting plagiarised work, whilst other students received a mark of zero. Plagiarism should therefore be taken seriously by all students.
Avoiding plagiarism is fairly straightforward. If a student is unsure as to whether or not something in their work counts as plagiarism, they are advised to consult a member of staff within their department before submitting it.
Care should be taken when collecting notes to ensure that all sources are correctly referenced in the essay’s footnotes and bibliography.
Students are advised when note-taking to carefully record the correct page number, book title and publication details. Managing your time appropriately can also ensure you avoid plagiarism, since lack of time may be responsible for insufficient or careless referencing.
All departments within Durham University take plagiarism very seriously, and with the potential consequences so severe, all students are advised to consult the guidelines if they are unsure.
For more information, visit the ‘Avoiding Plagiarism’ tutorial on DUO and the ‘University Guidance on Procedures in respect of Assessment Irregularities’ at www.dur.ac.uk/learningandteaching.handbook/6/3/5/
