Cuthsgate
Sometimes heat does generate light. I can’t say much about the usefulness or Rachael Revesz’s or Will Day’s criticisms of Cuth’s in the pages of the comment section, mainly because I know nothing about and care nothing for college politics. But I would guess that they have had some kind of positive impact, for the simple reason that they have easily resulted in more feedback than any other comment articles we have published in the last few years.
As far as I can see these articles are not inflammatory or unreasonable: they are not written with controversy in mind. They have simply become controversial by virtue of their sincere and measured content. In my experience people tend to feel more wounded by criticism that rings true than they do by criticism which rings false.
Which brings me to the subject of libel. There is a South Park episode about Scientology at the end of which Tom Cruise announces that he is going to England. The reason is that British libel law is the international envy of the cowardly and the corrupt: it is written in such a way as to give room for reparations for hurt feelings. Nick Cohen summarise the issue well here: http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2009/jan/30/civil-liberties-libel-law
It is an old argument, worth renewing. In ‘The Quintessence of Ibsenism’, George Bernard Shaw notes that the genuinely moral are rarely outraged by alleged impurity… “much as libel actions are mostly brought by persons concerning whom libels are virtually, if not technically, justifiable.”
This is why the spirit of good journalism has always been ‘publish and be damned’. Unfortunately it is a spirit that has been eroded for commercial reasons as well as by cowardliness. I’m very glad that in the face of a libel threat our editor has stood firm against such gross childishness. Nobody making this threat has asked for the opportunity to respond in a comment article. They prefer to shelter anonymously behind an illiberal mechanism for the silencing of criticism. Hopefully one day this law will change, but in the meantime the best we can do is to show that public opinion is behind open debate and to affirm that those who dislike criticism should, to coin a phrase, grow up.
