Philosophy Exam Chair resigns; University responds to his comments on AI
By Jasmine Davey
Durham University’s Chair of the Board of Examiners for Philosophy resigned over concerns about the University’s handling of student AI use in exams.
In a Spectator article published on Sunday, Professor Andy Hamilton argues that “the lazy student cheats with professional-grade versions of AI chatbots such as ChatGPT or Claude, and gets a first-class result. The hard-working student uses no bots, or a non-professional bot honestly, thinking and writing for themselves, but gets a 2:1.” A University spokesperson responded directly to this claim, calling it a “personal opinion, unsubstantiated and grossly unfair to current and former students.”
Professor Hamilton blames the Vice Chancellors, who he says have adopted the “ostrich position”, for this system. The University says this is a “personal opinion and unsubstantiated”, writing that “Durham University has addressed AI and assessment directly through its academic governance” in a rebuttal.
Regarding his resignation, Professor Hamilton argued it was his “responsibility” to highlight the significance of AI chatbots in online examinations, which he referred to as “a vital issue in higher education, one whose true significance is not understood”. Though the article’s headline and focus centre Durham, he writes that “my complaint is not against Durham University” but that he sees a wider issue with the higher education sector.
Professor Hamilton argued it was his “responsibility” to highlight the significance of AI chatbots in online examinations
Professor Hamilton recommended a return to sit-down examinations as “the obvious solution”, while describing abandoning anonymous marking as the “least-worst immediate alternative”. He argued this would counteract what he described as the current “chaotic system of guesswork”.
The University responded to the recommendation to return to in-person examination, claiming “Traditional invigilated exams are one AI-secure assessment method”, and that many other methods, such as “in-person oral assessments, presentations, practical work, process-based assessment etc.” are already employed in Durham programmes.
The University said Professor Hamilton’s proposal of abandoning anonymous marking was based on “personal opinion, with no factual evidence to back [it] up” and said it would “not address the core issue and would risk undermining established safeguards designed to ensure fairness and consistency.”
The University spokesperson went on to claim that “At a recent meeting, while the writer’s colleagues understood his concerns, they did not think that the solutions that he was presenting were workable. “
The University went on to describe Professor Hamilton’s claim that “universities say [a return to sit-down exams] are financially impractical” as “factually incorrect”. The University says it has “never said this”, asserting that it does not decide assessment methods based on financial considerations.
After marking in April, Professor Hamilton says the “true horrors of the situation” became apparent to him. Her believes that “with existing tools, AI cheating is almost impossible to prove except by student confession.” The University has rebutted this claim, saying “We have systems in place if cheating is detected as the writer suggests. Markers are expected to follow these processes.”
He also claimed the system disproportionately affects working class students, as “many Durham students can afford” professional versions of AI chatbots. The University rebuttal described this as “personal opinion and unsubstantiated.”
Durham University’s policy on AI use has been approved by the Senate, which contains all Heads of Departments. According to the University, Departmental Boards of Studies have been “actively engaged in reviewing and adapting assessment in their disciplines”. The University therefore stresses that academic staff are central to the design of its AI policy.
As well as responding to individual claims, Durham University published a rebuttal of the whole article:
“We wholly reject the allegations made in an article published online by The Spectator on Sunday 7 June, 2026.
We wholly reject the allegations made in an article published online by The Spectator on Sunday 7 June, 2026 – Durham University
“Many universities, including Durham, are addressing actively the use of artificial intelligence and what this emerging technology means for teaching, assessment and the career prospects of our students.
“Colleagues may articulate their own perspectives on these technological developments. However, we strongly dispute the assertions made in this article. They are personal opinion and unsubstantiated.”
Image credit: Rose Innes

