Oxford University students agree that “capitalism has failed the poor”

by Katie Pavid

The Oxford Union played host to a debate on the proposition: “This House Believes that Capitalism has Failed the Poor”, held 16th February 2012.

Speakers in proposition were Sir Ronald Cohen, co-founder of Apax Partners, Chairman of the Social Investment Task Force and Big Society Capital; Peter Taaffe, General Secretary of the Socialist Party; Michael Brindle QC, barrister at Fountain Court Chambers; and Scott Ralston, coach of the UAE School’s Debating Team.

Peter Taaffe argued that capitalism has not only failed the poor, but society as a whole, that this crisis was not episodic, but systemic, that it was failing the peoples of the world and needed to be replaced by a more rational system of democratic socialism.

Taaffe later pointed to mass unemployment and the recent events in Greece to demonstrate that capitalism was now an absolute fetter to the further development of society. His support of the Greek workers’ call for the cancellation of the debt and the nationalisation of the banks met with applause from the audience.

The other speakers arguing for the motion all made damning points about various aspects of capitalism’s deficiencies.

The speakers for the opposition were John Longworth, Director General of the  British Chambers of Commerce; Lord Grantley, former leader of the UK Independence Party in the House of Lords; Andrew Bridgen, Conservative MP; and Dr Madsen Pirie, President of the Adam Smith Institute. 

The opposition justified many aspects of capitalism. John Longworth’s suggestion that British workers should be happy that the gap between rich and poor in this country was not as great as elsewhere was described as “incredible” by the Socialist Party.

Andrew Brigden, Conservative MP, denied that there were any real poor in Britain, and said that the high figures on poverty were just a statistical scam, that family breakdown, failing teachers, and immigration were to blame, and that bad government and the corrupt state were untrustworthy forces to solve problems.

All the speakers against the motion claimed that capitalism should be allowed to operate freely without government or state interference, and argued that capitalism was the only viable system and was still progressive.

The motion was carried by the Union.