Overlooked depictions of bisexual women in literature

By Amber Tait

This month is LGBT history month, and I want to use this opportunity to shed some light on one of my favourite forgotten pieces of literature that focused around bisexual women. I discovered Pages For You in Affleck’s in Manchester last year, and felt as if I had picked up a piece of literature that was written just for me. Pages For You follows Flannery, an aspiring writer who starts her first year at the elite Yale University. We are transported to a world of ivy-covered walls, where Flannery experiences her queer awakening. 

Flannery, 17, meets Anne, 28, a teaching assistant at Yale in a chance encounter in a coffee shop and is immediately infatuated with her. Flannery’s feelings are strong, and undeniably adolescent – contrasting harshly to the older, more experienced Anne. 

The affair, as told from Flannery’s perspective, encapsulates the infatuation one feels over their first love. The blend of poetic rhythm and prose creates a dream like trance throughout the narrative; a comforting effect, yet somewhat bewildering at times. Brownrigg perfectly creates a literary experience of a young relationship. Her use of short chapters creates a maladaptive daydream effect; reading Pages for You is like reading an epic poem that transports you through a transitive stream of consciousness. The best way I can describe it, is dream like. Brownrigg used a combination of poetry and prose and a heart-breaking ending as a perfect recipe for a classic romance novel. 

The comforting romantic feel of the novel is complimented by its coming-of-age narrative

The comforting romantic feel of the novel is complimented by its coming-of-age narrative, where Flannery experiences the world in its entirety for the first time, as well as experiencing her first love. 

Despite my love for this novel, there are various issues I do have with it. Firstly, the age difference and power dynamic between Flannery and Anne is somewhat cringeworthy – the eleven-year age gap, and Anne’s position as a teaching assistant at Yale whilst Flannery is a student is somewhat questionable, although her position almost seems to add to the fantasy of the relationship. It seems to readers, incredibly understandable, and relatable, why Flannery is so infatuated with this older, experienced, educated and academic woman. 

Pages for You is followed by a more recent sequel, Pages For Her, in which the characters of Flannery and Anne are revisited twenty years on. Pages for Her differs to Pages for You in so many ways. Pages for You is paced in such a delicate way that it flows perfectly, and you will not want it to end. The definitive moments in the novel are painful and bittersweet, and the catharsis felt once you read those final pages is unparalleled. However, Pages for Her is a desperate attempt to finally reach the moment where Anne and Flannery reunite after twenty years. It’s a good sort of pain, in my experience, but it is an entirely different experience to Pages for You, where you never want the carefully crafted lines of poetry to end.

My issue with Pages for Her predominantly lies in Brownrigg’s depiction of bisexual women

My issue with Pages for Her predominantly lies in Brownrigg’s depiction of bisexual women. Both Flannery and Anne, twenty years later are now sharing their lives with men, only for Anne to suddenly end up single, and for Flannery to cheat on her husband, with Anne. Throughout the novel Flannery is emotionally involved with Anne, despite their lack of contact, and the whole portrayal seems far too stereotypical. This sort of narrative is tackled more directly by growing cult classics like The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo, yet I still find a very specific type of appeal in both novels that does not exist in Evelyn Hugo’s universe. 

Fundamentally, Pages for You is realistic, and Pages for Her offers us the hope that realism cannot always provide. I am the first to praise The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo, and I think it is an excellent book that has educated people on bisexuality, as well as successfully appealing to an audience that is wider than the LGBTQ+ community, increasing tolerance and acceptance – but Pages for You offers a tale that is much closer to home, despite reading like a daydream. The youthful digressions Flannery navigates are a universal experience, whereas Evelyn Hugo offers a magical narrative of escapism. That’s not to say that one is better than the other; they simply offer similar tales in very different ways. 

Pages for You and Pages for Her are appealing in a multitude of ways: English Literature students will adore the scholastic literary setting, women who like women will adore the whirlwind of a narrative in both books, fans of The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo will admire the poeticism of Pages for You, and the pining and longing explored in Pages for Her. Ultimately, these are two novels that I believe deserve much more attention, despite their imperfect depictions of sexuality, and questionable age gaps and power dynamics within relationships. These flaws, however, provide readers with a sense of reality, and a drop of hope that their own stories will end happily too.

Image Credit: Alexander Grey via Unsplash

https://www.dunelm.org.uk/donations/palatinateusing