Offending people is what comment is all about
It can be a nerve-racking experience, to see your opinions circulated en masse. If, say, a thousand people read this article, isn’t it likely that many of them will find fault with it? Don’t I have to be extremely careful with my words?
Yet the only space in which interesting, thought-provoking opinion can exist is that near-proverbial space referred to as ‘outside the box’. There is very little point in arguing for a position that everyone agrees with.
If we are to make more controversial claims, however, then we must accept our own vulnerability to criticism. We must work hard to convince others that we genuinely have ‘thought outside the box’, rather than simply having identified the box and positioned ourselves outside it without any thought at all.
What any thinking person should disapprove of is the automatic reaction of certain small-minded people against ideas which frighten them. As a general rule, it is this reflex that is at work whenever anyone claims to be offended by a point-of-view. The familiar complaint of victimhood is invoked whenever an argument looks to be heading towards thoughts that are too dangerous to be considered.
A case in point is the literary critic Terry Eagleton’s attack on the novelist Martin Amis.
If Chris Gribbin’s defence of Amis (page 7) doesn’t convince you, I suggest you read Amis’s new collection of articles relating to Islamism, The Second Plane, which serves as a treatise against the loss of moral and intellectual integrity involved in Western ‘liberal’ responses to terrorism.
If, having read this book, you still think that Amis is basically a racist who is obsessed with jihadism because he hates Muslims, or Arabs, or foreigners generally, then I admire your stubbornness.
Amis, along with writers such as Christopher Hitchens and Nick Cohen, is hoping to learn from the example of Orwell, whose great achievement was to puncture the tendency of leftwing intellectuals in the West to sympathise with the USSR and overlook Stalinist atrocities.
But whenever Amis speaks out today there is always someone, a Ken Livingstone or a George Galloway or a Guardian columnist, who shouts ‘racist!’ or ‘imperialist!’ as if that is the end of the debate. No doubt there will be some readers who are tempted to respond in a similar fashion to Edwin Smith’s criticisms of DICCU (overleaf).
There is a strongly ingrained habit of thought which presumes that it is unfair or rude to criticise anything to do with a person’s religion. How dare some atheist march in and tell me that there is something wrong with the way I think?
Whatever we think of those combative atheists (Dawkins, Dennett, Hitchens, Harris et al.) who believe religion in general is irrational and harmful, it seems to me quite clear, for the reasons that Edwin gives, that DICCU is an arrogant and aggressive organisation.
It is not just that there is in our society a group of people with a strange and silly worldview, it is that they are represented by a large and vocal group who seem to expect the rest of us to be convinced by their arguments, despite the fact that they barely have any arguments at all. Just listening to them would win us over, if only we weren’t so closed-minded!
What does it say about Christianity today that the umbrella-organisation for the colleges’ Christian groups in this university appears to be fundamentalist and uncompromising? Shouldn’t moderate Christians be outraged by DICCU? Or is the unthinkable truth behind ‘Know Truth Week’ in actual fact that there is no coherent and compelling way of being a non-fundamentalist Christian?
To put it another way, does the Bible lose its power to inspire belief if parts of it have to be ignored or revised?
I leave this as an open question. Edwin Smith’s argument is much more mature than this, but it will nonetheless be met with anger and frustration from certain individuals.
I hope that the opinion-merchants of Durham’s various media outlets will continue to provoke, annoy and be rude about those who are not embarrassed by their own backwardness. Religion, of course, does not have a monopoly on backwardness. There was nothing religious, for example, about Letitia Clark’s article for the Gossip section of The Sanctuary, which consisted of cruel and ill-informed ridicule of Durham’s Big Issue sellers.
I have no desire to undermine the contribution that The Sanctuary makes to the student journalism scene. Its editors and writers work hard to produce journalism on their own initiative, which makes it all the more sad that Clark’s article was allowed to lower the tone.
The article contained the phrases “holy women”, “illegal immigrants” and “smelled them” in reference to real human beings who walk the very same streets that are regularly littered with discarded copies of student papers. Those phrases are taken out of context, of course, but I challenge you to imagine a context in which they could be appropriate. It should be unthinkable to identify specific human beings and attack them like this, and would obviously be so if the human beings in question were not what Clark calls “weirdoes”.
Clark has the nerve to argue that there’s no point in buying the Big Issue, since its “delivery of the English language positively repels you.” As opposed to Clark’s eloquent and precise prose style? Someone who compares the request of these women (‘Big Issue please?’) first to an “endless litany” and then, just a few lines later, to a “mating call”, should not be so quick to accuse a philanthropic publishing venture of literary ineptitude!
Clark might also be well-advised to meet some of the people she stigmatises, such as the highly articulate Durham graduate whom Clark calls “Cap’n Birdseye” – on the stunningly perspicacious grounds, it would seem, that they are both old men with beards. It might be pointed out that the fish-advertising Captain’s beard is short and white, while the man in question’s is more like Charles Darwin’s. But we wouldn’t want anything as inconvenient as facts to get in the way of a good chuckle at an outsider, would we?
Clark should try talking to her ‘Cap’n Birdseye’: The enemy, he once informed me, is wilful ignorance. Clark’s article is a case in point. If you are inclined to backwardness, then that is unfortunate for you, and we will politely skirt around the issue. But if you publish your backwardness in a newspaper, or wear it on a hoody – Know Truth! – then the rest of us have a right, if not a duty, to laugh your opinions out of court.
