How did we come to censor our novelists?
It began innocuously enough. In September 2006 during an interview with The Times Martin Amis wondered aloud about his “definite urge… to say the Muslim community will have to suffer until it gets its house in order…
“Curtailing of freedoms… discriminatory stuff.”
Amis’s wonderings lay dormant until August last year when Terry Eagleton, his fellow professor at Manchester University, struck back in ferocious style attacking Amis’s ideas as ‘the ramblings of a British National Party thug.’ Eagleton went on to call Amis’s father (Kingsley Amis) ‘a racist, anti-Semitic boor.’
That salvo from Eagleton proved to be the movement that ignited a storm, one that has thundered nosily throughout last autumn at the very top of academia, drawing terrorism, racism, and censorship in to its wake.
It is perhaps worth noting that Eagleton’s bile was inspired by a mere ‘urge’ of Amis’s, a conjecture that Amis neither argued in favour of, nor against.
That Eagleton struck back with such violence – and that, in all the subsequent coverage, minimal attention has actually been paid to Amis’s suggestions – is testament to the present climate of twitchiness when it comes to open ended debate.
Such reactionary sensitivity is echoed by Gordon Brown’s decision not to attend the EU-Africa conference last December to sit and talk with Robert Mugabe.
The government’s refusal to talk to the Taliban in Afghanistan is borne out of an apparently similar reluctance to engage in open and free debate.
Yet whenever anyone – whether in government or the media – attempts to distil the British identity it is ideals of ‘freedom’ and ‘fair play’ which are thrown about.
The present conflicts in Afghanistan and Iraq are often painted as opportunities to export these very values.
Indeed, before policies are launched, the government pledges ‘a conversation’ with the nation, and affects to listen to different ideas.
The concept of listening is omnipresent, but so rarely actualised.
Beside the difficulty of actually having a conversation with a nation, the government is conscious it has been elected and is in a very insular ivory tower; it simply doesn’t have to listen.
Freedom of speech is very often extolled, but whilst it is important, it means nothing if there is – as with Eagleton and Brown – a refusal to engage.
Open debate is always absolutely necessary in order to advance and develop any ideas. To ignore other views by refusing to engage with them is destructive and leads to an empty stasis incapable of progression.
Amis’s ideas can not be rejected out of hand simply because they offend our sensibilities; laying back and attacking the father of the man whose ideas you disagree will prove nothing.
Of course, such ad hominem attacks only add fuel to Amis’s ideas; posing as a martyr for free speech is how almost every oppositional idea gathers attention and subsequent support.
Refusing to engage also gives such opinions an isolated validity, without countering views they can attain credibility to the point where refusal to engage is no longer possible and the issues at hand are no longer abstractly conceptual.
If, as a society, we truly believe in our positive values we must be brave enough to place our faith in such values emerging victorious from the forum of debate.
To shy from debate with Amis, or with Mugabe for that matter, is futile and reactionary – a pre-emptive admission of weakness.
To resist ignoring views and, instead, to engage in an open and honest challenge to such opinions, however, can only prove to be healthy and have a restorative effect upon the beliefs we claim to trust.
A true faith in the power of reasonable reasoning would not only overcome the ugly name-calling of the Amis-Eagleton spat, but would also instill society with a proven and genuine faith in the values it calls its own.
